Member of Parliament

Mr Alistair Carmichael

LD Liberal Democrat Orkney and Shetland ID 1442

Parliamentary Parliamentary Constituency Constituency Constituency Constituency

Overview Votes Expenses Activity EDMs Alignment History Interests

Voting alignment

Mr Alistair Carmichael has 636 current-MP voting relationships with at least 50 shared comparable votes. These lists show the MPs who most often voted the same way, and the MPs who most often voted differently, when both recorded an Aye or No vote.

Explore Commons-wide voting alignment →

Most similar MPs

Highest same-vote percentages against Mr Alistair Carmichael.

Exclude own party

Cameron Thomas 100%

Ind Tewkesbury

224 same 1 different 225 shared

Compare

Judith Cummins 98%

Lab Bradford South

917 same 17 different 934 shared

Compare

Liz Saville Roberts 97%

PC Dwyfor Meirionnydd

1,152 same 41 different 1,193 shared

Compare

Ben Lake 97%

PC Ceredigion Preseli

1,111 same 39 different 1,150 shared

Compare

Brendan O'Hara 97%

SNP Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber

986 same 28 different 1,014 shared

Compare

Kirsty Blackman 97%

SNP Aberdeen North

951 same 29 different 980 shared

Compare

Pete Wishart 97%

SNP Perth and Kinross-shire

922 same 26 different 948 shared

Compare

Rosie Duffield 97%

Ind Canterbury

888 same 29 different 917 shared

Compare

Chris Law 97%

SNP Dundee Central

885 same 29 different 914 shared

Compare

Dave Doogan 96%

SNP Angus and Perthshire Glens

551 same 24 different 575 shared

Compare

Rachel Reeves 95%

Lab Leeds West and Pudsey

852 same 47 different 899 shared

Compare

Jeremy Corbyn 94%

YP Islington North

986 same 59 different 1,045 shared

Compare

Claire Hanna 94%

SDLP Belfast South and Mid Down

530 same 35 different 565 shared

Compare

Pat McFadden 92%

Lab Wolverhampton South East

1,027 same 94 different 1,121 shared

Compare

Yvette Cooper 92%

Lab Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley

1,022 same 87 different 1,109 shared

Compare

Shabana Mahmood 92%

Lab Birmingham Ladywood

864 same 72 different 936 shared

Compare

Mr David Lammy 92%

Lab Tottenham

844 same 70 different 914 shared

Compare

John Healey 91%

Lab Rawmarsh and Conisbrough

954 same 89 different 1,043 shared

Compare

Ed Miliband 91%

Lab Doncaster North

877 same 88 different 965 shared

Compare

Colum Eastwood 91%

SDLP Foyle

576 same 57 different 633 shared

Compare

Peter Kyle 90%

Lab Hove and Portslade

972 same 104 different 1,076 shared

Compare

Wes Streeting 90%

Lab Ilford North

922 same 108 different 1,030 shared

Compare

Dr Rosena Allin-Khan 90%

Lab Tooting

826 same 88 different 914 shared

Compare

Lisa Nandy 90%

Lab Wigan

812 same 87 different 899 shared

Compare

Stephen Doughty 89%

Lab Cardiff South and Penarth

995 same 120 different 1,115 shared

Compare

Most different MPs

Lowest same-vote percentages against Mr Alistair Carmichael.

Ms Nusrat Ghani 6%

Con Sussex Weald

66 same 958 different 1,024 shared

Compare

Rishi Sunak 7%

Con Richmond and Northallerton

54 same 677 different 731 shared

Compare

Caroline Nokes 8%

Con Romsey and Southampton North

82 same 927 different 1,009 shared

Compare

Mrs Kemi Badenoch 11%

Con North West Essex

113 same 882 different 995 shared

Compare

Sarah Smith 12%

Lab Hyndburn

24 same 172 different 196 shared

Compare

Suella Braverman 13%

RUK Fareham and Waterlooville

154 same 1,004 different 1,158 shared

Compare

Robert Jenrick 13%

RUK Newark

150 same 984 different 1,134 shared

Compare

Kirith Entwistle 13%

Lab Bolton North East

34 same 220 different 254 shared

Compare

Antonia Bance 13%

Lab Tipton and Wednesbury

29 same 193 different 222 shared

Compare

Sir John Whittingdale 14%

Con Maldon

182 same 1,093 different 1,275 shared

Compare

Sir Jeremy Wright 14%

Con Kenilworth and Southam

162 same 964 different 1,126 shared

Compare

Sir Geoffrey Cox 14%

Con Torridge and Tavistock

152 same 947 different 1,099 shared

Compare

Sir Andrew Mitchell 14%

Con Sutton Coldfield

148 same 879 different 1,027 shared

Compare

Douglas McAllister 14%

Lab West Dunbartonshire

39 same 233 different 272 shared

Compare

Jen Craft 14%

Lab Thurrock

35 same 214 different 249 shared

Compare

Anneliese Midgley 14%

Lab Knowsley

35 same 209 different 244 shared

Compare

Martin McCluskey 14%

Lab Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West

31 same 195 different 226 shared

Compare

Mike Reader 14%

Lab Northampton South

31 same 187 different 218 shared

Compare

Olivia Bailey 14%

Lab Reading West and Mid Berkshire

30 same 180 different 210 shared

Compare

Maya Ellis 14%

Lab Ribble Valley

28 same 169 different 197 shared

Compare

Sir Desmond Swayne 15%

Con New Forest West

217 same 1,187 different 1,404 shared

Compare

Sir Mel Stride 15%

Con Central Devon

187 same 1,065 different 1,252 shared

Compare

Dame Caroline Dinenage 15%

Con Gosport

191 same 1,055 different 1,246 shared

Compare

Sir Alec Shelbrooke 15%

Con Wetherby and Easingwold

188 same 1,035 different 1,223 shared

Compare

Sir Edward Leigh 15%

Con Gainsborough

176 same 1,028 different 1,204 shared

Compare

Voting source Commons Votes API

Method Only divisions where both MPs recorded comparable Aye/No votes are included. Tellers, absences, abstentions, and missing votes are excluded.