Member of Parliament

Andy McDonald

Lab Labour Middlesbrough and Thornaby East ID 4269

Parliamentary Parliamentary Constituency

Voting alignment

Andy McDonald has 638 current-MP voting relationships with at least 50 shared comparable votes. These lists show the MPs who most often voted the same way, and the MPs who most often voted differently, when both recorded an Aye or No vote.

Explore Commons-wide voting alignment →

Most similar MPs

Highest same-vote percentages against Andy McDonald.

Exclude own party

Karl Turner 99%

Ind Kingston upon Hull East

1,191 same 8 different 1,199 shared

Compare

Colum Eastwood 97%

SDLP Foyle

698 same 24 different 722 shared

Compare

Claire Hanna 97%

SDLP Belfast South and Mid Down

600 same 17 different 617 shared

Compare

Mr Bayo Alaba 97%

Ind Southend East and Rochford

350 same 10 different 360 shared

Compare

Dan Norris 96%

Ind North East Somerset and Hanham

366 same 17 different 383 shared

Compare

Jeremy Corbyn 92%

YP Islington North

1,181 same 101 different 1,282 shared

Compare

Rosie Duffield 92%

Ind Canterbury

966 same 81 different 1,047 shared

Compare

Zarah Sultana 92%

YP Coventry South

958 same 89 different 1,047 shared

Compare

Kirsty Blackman 92%

SNP Aberdeen North

927 same 85 different 1,012 shared

Compare

Chris Law 92%

SNP Dundee Central

895 same 82 different 977 shared

Compare

Brendan O'Hara 91%

SNP Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber

972 same 94 different 1,066 shared

Compare

Pete Wishart 91%

SNP Perth and Kinross-shire

904 same 88 different 992 shared

Compare

Dave Doogan 87%

SNP Angus and Perthshire Glens

545 same 82 different 627 shared

Compare

Liz Saville Roberts 86%

PC Dwyfor Meirionnydd

1,144 same 179 different 1,323 shared

Compare

Ben Lake 86%

PC Ceredigion Preseli

1,093 same 183 different 1,276 shared

Compare

Mr Alistair Carmichael 82%

LD Orkney and Shetland

1,031 same 234 different 1,265 shared

Compare

Ed Davey 81%

LD Kingston and Surbiton

865 same 200 different 1,065 shared

Compare

Christine Jardine 80%

LD Edinburgh West

911 same 224 different 1,135 shared

Compare

Wera Hobhouse 79%

LD Bath

991 same 260 different 1,251 shared

Compare

Tim Farron 79%

LD Westmorland and Lonsdale

958 same 251 different 1,209 shared

Compare

Jamie Stone 78%

LD Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross

912 same 254 different 1,166 shared

Compare

Layla Moran 77%

LD Oxford West and Abingdon

901 same 275 different 1,176 shared

Compare

Sarah Olney 74%

LD Richmond Park

733 same 254 different 987 shared

Compare

Wendy Chamberlain 72%

LD North East Fife

668 same 255 different 923 shared

Compare

Munira Wilson 70%

LD Twickenham

714 same 300 different 1,014 shared

Compare

Most different MPs

Lowest same-vote percentages against Andy McDonald.

Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst 3%

Con Solihull West and Shirley

11 same 388 different 399 shared

Compare

Mr Peter Bedford 3%

Con Mid Leicestershire

10 same 364 different 374 shared

Compare

Sir Ashley Fox 3%

Con Bridgwater

9 same 349 different 358 shared

Compare

Aphra Brandreth 3%

Con Chester South and Eddisbury

10 same 319 different 329 shared

Compare

Sir Desmond Swayne 4%

Con New Forest West

60 same 1,536 different 1,596 shared

Compare

Sir John Hayes 4%

Con South Holland and The Deepings

66 same 1,433 different 1,499 shared

Compare

Sir John Whittingdale 4%

Con Maldon

60 same 1,405 different 1,465 shared

Compare

John Lamont 4%

Con Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk

60 same 1,340 different 1,400 shared

Compare

Neil O'Brien 4%

Con Harborough, Oadby and Wigston

59 same 1,325 different 1,384 shared

Compare

Sir Edward Leigh 4%

Con Gainsborough

54 same 1,329 different 1,383 shared

Compare

Sir Geoffrey Cox 4%

Con Torridge and Tavistock

55 same 1,198 different 1,253 shared

Compare

Priti Patel 4%

Con Witham

53 same 1,147 different 1,200 shared

Compare

Richard Fuller 4%

Con North Bedfordshire

50 same 1,101 different 1,151 shared

Compare

Gareth Bacon 4%

Con Orpington

43 same 1,073 different 1,116 shared

Compare

Greg Smith 4%

Con Mid Buckinghamshire

43 same 1,069 different 1,112 shared

Compare

Dr Luke Evans 4%

Con Hinckley and Bosworth

43 same 1,039 different 1,082 shared

Compare

Matt Vickers 4%

Con Stockton West

42 same 960 different 1,002 shared

Compare

Andrew Griffith 4%

Con Arundel and South Downs

41 same 954 different 995 shared

Compare

Danny Kruger 4%

RUK East Wiltshire

44 same 938 different 982 shared

Compare

Joy Morrissey 4%

Con Beaconsfield

40 same 931 different 971 shared

Compare

Laura Trott 4%

Con Sevenoaks

41 same 878 different 919 shared

Compare

Mr Louie French 4%

Con Old Bexley and Sidcup

32 same 706 different 738 shared

Compare

Peter Fortune 4%

Con Bromley and Biggin Hill

16 same 349 different 365 shared

Compare

Mr Andrew Snowden 4%

Con Fylde

11 same 287 different 298 shared

Compare

Edward Argar 5%

Con Melton and Syston

83 same 1,539 different 1,622 shared

Compare

Voting source Commons Votes API

Method Only divisions where both MPs recorded comparable Aye/No votes are included. Tellers, absences, abstentions, and missing votes are excluded.