At a glance
This division was rejected on 29 March 2017 by a margin of 59, with 230 Ayes and 289 Noes. The largest Aye bloc was Labour with 157 votes. The largest No bloc was Conservative with 255 votes. The 112 MPs who did not vote outnumbered the margin — enough to have changed the result. This motion was proposed by The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Pensions. This division took place during a debate on Pension Schemes Bill [Lords].
230
Ayes
289
Noes
Rejected
Result
471
Voted
The motion
Proposed by The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Pensions
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read the Third time. We return to this Bill after last Wednesday’s traumatic events. My thoughts and sympathies, and those of all the House, are with those who were affected. I take this opportunity to thank hon. Members from both sides of the House and the House… I beg to move, That the Bill be now read the Third time. We return to this Bill after last Wednesday’s traumatic events. My thoughts and sympathies, and those of all the House, are with those who were affected. I take this opportunity to thank hon. Members from both sides of the House and the House staff for their support and professionalism in what was a very difficult time for us all. I am pleased to see Madam Deputy Speaker in the Chair, as she has not heard any of this before. This Bill focuses on master trusts, introducing a new authorisation regime for them and setting out how they must satisfy the Pensions Regulator of certain criteria before they can begin, or continue, to operate. The criteria were developed in discussion with the industry, and respond to specific key risks. Although the Bill provides some detail, more will be set out in regulations after further consultation with the industry and others. The Bill gives the regulator new powers to supervise master trusts, and to step in when schemes risk falling below the required standards. It also gives the regulator additional powers when a master trust experiences a key risk event. A scheme that has experienced such an event will be required either to resolve the issue or to wind up. As well as giving the regulator new powers, this Bill supports continuity of savings for members, protects members when a scheme is to wind up, and supports employers with their automatic enrolment duties. To protect members of existing schemes, some aspects of the regime will have effect from 20 October 2016. Schemes are required to report triggering events to the regulator, and there are restrictions on certain charges until the event is resolved. The Bill also amends existing legislation so that regulations can override relevant contract terms that are inconsistent with those regulations. We intend to use this provision, along with existing powers, to make regulations that cap early exit charges and ban member-borne commission in some occupational pension schemes. When this Bill was introduced in the other place last October, it was welcomed across the pensions industry as an essential piece of legislation that would protect the millions of people now saving for their retirement through master trusts. I am pleased to say that the Bill has been broadly welcomed by those in all parts of both Houses. We have listened to the points raised in both Houses, and have continued to engage with stakeholders. I can confirm that we have brought forward a number of Government amendments to address their concerns. In the other place, amendments in Committee mainly related to how the regulator would enforce the new authorisation regime. Amendments on Report in the Lords focused on regulation-making powers in the Bill, in acknowledgement of the report from the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee. One amendment inserted a power to make limited consequential changes to legislation to ensure that the law works as it should. We also made a change to allow the provisions on fraud compensation in the Pensions Act 2004 to be modified for master trusts. On Third Reading in the Lords, we made one minor technical change to clarify that regulations on scheme funders’ accounts may require them to be audited. In Committee in this House, we agreed further changes. First, the Committee removed a clause that had been inserted after a narrow vote on Report in the other place, which provided for a scheme funder of last resort to meet the costs when a master trust is being wound up without the necessary funds to transfer the accrued benefits. We discussed that once again on Report last week, when the House accepted the Government’s argument that this additional provision is unnecessary. In response to a point raised in the other place about an unintended consequence of the Bill, we made amendments to enable a scheme funder to engage in activities in relation to any part of the scheme, not just the money
Party breakdown
Click a row to filter votes below by that party.
| Party | Party position | Ayes | Noes | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Con Conservative | Voted No | 0 | 255 | 289 |
| Lab Labour | Voted Aye | 157 | 0 | 188 |
| SNP Scottish National Party | Voted Aye | 40 | 0 | 54 |
| LD Liberal Democrat | Voted Aye | 8 | 0 | 14 |
| DUP Democratic Unionist Party | Voted No | 0 | 4 | 6 |
| PC Plaid Cymru | Voted Aye | 3 | 0 | 3 |
| SDLP Social Democratic & Labour Party | Voted Aye | 2 | 0 | 2 |
| Ind Independent | No party whip | 1 | 0 | 15 |
| UUP Ulster Unionist Party | Voted No | 0 | 1 | 1 |
| Lab Labour (Co-op) | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 6 |
| YP Your Party | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Spk Speaker | No party whip | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Green Green Party | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| IGC The Independent Group for Change | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| SF Sinn Féin | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
"Party position" is how the majority of each party's voting members voted in this division. Parliament does not publish official whipping instructions, so this is derived from the recorded votes. "Rebels" are members who voted against their party's majority; Independent and Speaker roles have no party whip.
Individual votes
| Compare | MP | Party | Constituency | Vote | Rebel |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Afriyie | Con | Windsor | No | ||
| Adam Holloway | Con | Gravesham | No | ||
| Alan Brown | SNP | Kilmarnock and Loudoun | Aye | ||
| Alan Johnson | Lab | Kingston upon Hull West and Hessle | Aye | ||
| Alan Mak | Con | Havant | No | ||
| Albert Owen | Lab | Ynys Môn | Aye | ||
| Alberto Costa | Con | South Leicestershire | No | ||
| Alex Chalk | Con | Cheltenham | No | ||
| Alex Cunningham | Lab | Stockton North | Aye | ||
| Alex Salmond | SNP | Gordon | Aye | ||
| Alison McGovern | Lab | Birkenhead | Aye | ||
| Alistair Burt | Con | North East Bedfordshire | No | ||
| Amanda Solloway | Con | Derby North | No | ||
| Amber Rudd | Con | Hastings and Rye | No | ||
| Andrea Leadsom | Con | South Northamptonshire | No | ||
| Andrew Bridgen | Con | North West Leicestershire | No | ||
| Andrew Griffiths | Con | Burton | No | ||
| Andrew Gwynne | Lab | Gorton and Denton | Aye | ||
| Andrew Jones | Con | Harrogate and Knaresborough | No | ||
| Andrew Percy | Con | Brigg and Goole | No | ||
| Andrew Rosindell | Con | Romford | No | ||
| Andrew Selous | Con | South West Bedfordshire | No | ||
| Andrew Stephenson | Con | Pendle | No | ||
| Andy Burnham | Lab | Makerfield | Aye | ||
| Andy McDonald | Lab | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East | Aye | ||
| Andy Slaughter | Lab | Hammersmith and Chiswick | Aye | ||
| Angela Rayner | Lab | Ashton-under-Lyne | Aye | ||
| Angela Smith | Lab | Penistone and Stocksbridge | Aye | ||
| Angus Brendan MacNeil | SNP | Na h-Eileanan an Iar | Aye | ||
| Angus Robertson | SNP | Moray | Aye | ||
| Ann Clwyd | Lab | Cynon Valley | Aye | ||
| Ann Coffey | Lab | Stockport | Aye | ||
| Anna Soubry | Con | Broxtowe | No | ||
| Anna Turley | Lab | Redcar | Aye | ||
| Anne Marie Morris | Con | Newton Abbot | No | ||
| Anne Milton | Con | Guildford | No | ||
| Antoinette Sandbach | Con | Eddisbury | No | ||
| Barry Gardiner | Lab | Brent West | Aye | ||
| Ben Gummer | Con | Ipswich | No | ||
| Ben Howlett | Con | Bath | No | ||
| Bill Esterson | Lab | Sefton Central | Aye | ||
| Bob Blackman | Con | Harrow East | No | ||
| Bob Stewart | Con | Beckenham | No | ||
| Boris Johnson | Con | Uxbridge and South Ruislip | No | ||
| Brendan O'Hara | SNP | Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber | Aye | ||
| Bridget Phillipson | Lab | Houghton and Sunderland South | Aye | ||
| Callum McCaig | SNP | Aberdeen South | Aye | ||
| Calum Kerr | SNP | Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk | Aye | ||
| Caroline Ansell | Con | Eastbourne | No | ||
| Caroline Flint | Lab | Don Valley | Aye | ||
| Caroline Nokes | Con | Romsey and Southampton North | No | ||
| Carolyn Harris | Lab | Neath and Swansea East | Aye | ||
| Cat Smith | Lab | Lancaster and Wyre | Aye | ||
| Catherine McKinnell | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne North | Aye | ||
| Catherine West | Lab | Hornsey and Friern Barnet | Aye | ||
| Charlotte Leslie | Con | Bristol North West | No | ||
| Chris Bryant | Lab | Rhondda and Ogmore | Aye | ||
| Chris Davies | Con | Brecon and Radnorshire | No | ||
| Chris Green | Con | Bolton West | No | ||
| Chris Heaton-Harris | Con | Daventry | No Teller | ||
| Chris Law | SNP | Dundee Central | Aye | ||
| Chris Philp | Con | Croydon South | No | ||
| Chris Skidmore | Con | Kingswood | No | ||
| Chris Stephens | SNP | Glasgow South West | Aye | ||
| Chris White | Con | Warwick and Leamington | No | ||
| Christian Matheson | Lab | City of Chester | Aye | ||
| Christopher Pincher | Con | Tamworth | No Teller | ||
| Claire Perry | Con | Devizes | No | ||
| Clive Efford | Lab | Eltham and Chislehurst | Aye | ||
| Clive Lewis | Lab | Norwich South | Aye | ||
| Colleen Fletcher | Lab | Coventry North East | Aye | ||
| Conor McGinn | Lab | St Helens North | Aye | ||
| Corri Wilson | SNP | Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock | Aye | ||
| Craig Tracey | Con | North Warwickshire | No | ||
| Craig Whittaker | Con | Calder Valley | No | ||
| Craig Williams | Con | Montgomeryshire | No | ||
| Crispin Blunt | Con | Reigate | No | ||
| Dame Amanda Milling | Con | Cannock Chase | No | ||
| Dame Caroline Dinenage | Con | Gosport | No | ||
| Dame Caroline Spelman | Con | Meriden | No | ||
| Dame Cheryl Gillan | Con | Chesham and Amersham | No | ||
| Dame Chi Onwurah | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West | Aye | ||
| Dame Diana Johnson | Lab | Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham | Aye | ||
| Dame Harriett Baldwin | Con | West Worcestershire | No | ||
| Dame Jackie Doyle-Price | Con | Thurrock | No | ||
| Dame Louise Ellman | Lab | Liverpool, Riverside | Aye | ||
| Dame Maria Miller | Con | Basingstoke | No | ||
| Dame Meg Hillier | Lab | Hackney South and Shoreditch | Aye | ||
| Dame Nia Griffith | Lab | Llanelli | Aye | ||
| Dame Siobhain McDonagh | Lab | Mitcham and Morden | Aye | ||
| Dame Tracey Crouch | Con | Chatham and Aylesford | No | ||
| Damian Hinds | Con | East Hampshire | No | ||
| Dan Jarvis | Lab | Barnsley North | Aye | ||
| Daniel Kawczynski | Con | Shrewsbury and Atcham | No | ||
| Daniel Zeichner | Lab | Cambridge | Aye | ||
| Danny Kinahan | UUP | South Antrim | No | ||
| David Morris | Con | Morecambe and Lunesdale | No | ||
| David Mowat | Con | Warrington South | No | ||
| David Mundell | Con | Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale | No | ||
| David Rutley | Con | Macclesfield | No | ||
| David T C Davies | Con | Monmouth | No | ||
| David Tredinnick | Con | Bosworth | No | ||
| David Warburton | Con | Somerton and Frome | No | ||
| Dawn Butler | Lab | Brent East | Aye | ||
| Debbie Abrahams | Lab | Oldham East and Saddleworth | Aye | ||
| Deidre Brock | SNP | Edinburgh North and Leith | Aye | ||
| Derek Thomas | Con | St Ives | No | ||
| Derek Twigg | Lab | Widnes and Halewood | Aye | ||
| Dominic Raab | Con | Esher and Walton | No | ||
| Douglas Chapman | SNP | Dunfermline and West Fife | Aye | ||
| Dr Alasdair McDonnell | SDLP | Belfast South | Aye | ||
| Dr Andrew Murrison | Con | South West Wiltshire | No | ||
| Dr Caroline Johnson | Con | Sleaford and North Hykeham | No | ||
| Dr Dan Poulter | Con | Central Suffolk and North Ipswich | No | ||
| Dr Eilidh Whiteford | SNP | Banff and Buchan | Aye | ||
| Dr James Davies | Con | Vale of Clwyd | No | ||
| Dr Lisa Cameron | SNP | East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow | Aye | ||
| Dr Paul Monaghan | SNP | Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross | Aye | ||
| Dr Phillip Lee | Con | Bracknell | No | ||
| Dr Rosena Allin-Khan | Lab | Tooting | Aye | ||
| Dr Rupa Huq | Lab | Ealing Central and Acton | Aye | ||
| Dr Sarah Wollaston | Con | Totnes | No | ||
| Dr Tania Mathias | Con | Twickenham | No | ||
| Drew Hendry | SNP | Inverness, Nairn, Badenoch and Strathspey | Aye | ||
| Edward Argar | Con | Melton and Syston | No | ||
| Edward Timpson | Con | Eddisbury | No | ||
| Elizabeth Truss | Con | South West Norfolk | No | ||
| Emily Thornberry | Lab | Islington South and Finsbury | Aye | ||
| Emma Lewell | Lab | South Shields | Aye | ||
| Fiona Mactaggart | Lab | Slough | Aye | ||
| Gareth Johnson | Con | Dartford | No | ||
| Gareth Snell | Lab | Stoke-on-Trent Central | Aye | ||
| Gavin Newlands | SNP | Paisley and Renfrewshire North | Aye | ||
| Gavin Robinson | DUP | Belfast East | No | ||
| George Eustice | Con | Camborne and Redruth | No | ||
| George Freeman | Con | Mid Norfolk | No | ||
| George Kerevan | SNP | East Lothian | Aye | ||
| Gerald Jones | Lab | Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare | Aye | ||
| Gill Furniss | Lab | Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough | Aye | ||
| Gloria De Piero | Lab | Ashfield | Aye | ||
| Glyn Davies | Con | Montgomeryshire | No | ||
| Gordon Henderson | Con | Sittingbourne and Sheppey | No | ||
| Gordon Marsden | Lab | Blackpool South | Aye | ||
| Graham P Jones | Lab | Hyndburn | Aye | ||
| Graham Stringer | Lab | Blackley and Middleton South | Aye | ||
| Graham Stuart | Con | Beverley and Holderness | No | ||
| Grant Shapps | Con | Welwyn Hatfield | No | ||
| Greg Clark | Con | Tunbridge Wells | No | ||
| Greg Hands | Con | Chelsea and Fulham | No | ||
| Greg Mulholland | LD | Leeds North West | Aye | ||
| Guy Opperman | Con | Hexham | No | ||
| Hannah Bardell | SNP | Livingston | Aye | ||
| Heidi Alexander | Lab | Swindon South | Aye | ||
| Heidi Allen | Con | South Cambridgeshire | No | ||
| Helen Goodman | Lab | Bishop Auckland | Aye | ||
| Helen Grant | Con | Maidstone and Malling | No | ||
| Helen Hayes | Lab | Dulwich and West Norwood | Aye | ||
| Helen Whately | Con | Faversham and Mid Kent | No | ||
| Henry Smith | Con | Crawley | No | ||
| Hilary Benn | Lab | Leeds South | Aye | ||
| Holly Lynch | Lab | Halifax | Aye | ||
| Huw Merriman | Con | Bexhill and Battle | No | ||
| Hywel Williams | PC | Arfon | Aye | ||
| Iain Stewart | Con | Milton Keynes South | No | ||
| Ian Blackford | SNP | Ross, Skye and Lochaber | Aye | ||
| Ian Lavery | Lab | Blyth and Ashington | Aye | ||
| Ian Mearns | Lab | Gateshead | Aye | ||
| Ian Murray | Lab | Edinburgh South | Aye | ||
| Ian Paisley | DUP | North Antrim | No | ||
| Imran Hussain | Lab | Bradford East | Aye | ||
| Jack Dromey | Lab | Birmingham, Erdington | Aye | ||
| James Berry | Con | Kingston and Surbiton | No | ||
| James Cartlidge | Con | South Suffolk | No | ||
| James Heappey | Con | Wells | No | ||
| James Morris | Con | Halesowen and Rowley Regis | No | ||
| Jane Ellison | Con | Battersea | No | ||
| Jason McCartney | Con | Colne Valley | No | ||
| Jeff Smith | Lab | Manchester Withington | Aye Teller | ||
| Jeremy Lefroy | Con | Stafford | No | ||
| Jess Phillips | Lab | Birmingham Yardley | Aye | ||
| Jesse Norman | Con | Hereford and South Herefordshire | No | ||
| Jim Dowd | Lab | Lewisham West and Penge | Aye | ||
| Jim Fitzpatrick | Lab | Poplar and Limehouse | Aye | ||
| Jim McMahon | Lab | Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton | Aye | ||
| Jim Shannon | DUP | Strangford | No | ||
| Jo Churchill | Con | Bury St Edmunds | No | ||
| Joanna Cherry | SNP | Edinburgh South West | Aye | ||
| John Glen | Con | Salisbury | No | ||
| John Healey | Lab | Rawmarsh and Conisbrough | Aye | ||
| John Howell | Con | Henley | No | ||
| John McDonnell | Lab | Hayes and Harlington | Aye | ||
| John Penrose | Con | Weston-super-Mare | No | ||
| John Pugh | LD | Southport | Aye | ||
| John Stevenson | Con | Carlisle | No | ||
| Johnny Mercer | Con | Plymouth, Moor View | No | ||
| Jon Cruddas | Lab | Dagenham and Rainham | Aye | ||
| Jon Trickett | Lab | Normanton and Hemsworth | Aye | ||
| Jonathan Ashworth | Lab | Leicester South | Aye | ||
| Jonathan Edwards | PC | Carmarthen East and Dinefwr | Aye | ||
| Jonathan Reynolds | Lab | Stalybridge and Hyde | Aye | ||
| Judith Cummins | Lab | Bradford South | Aye | ||
| Julian Sturdy | Con | York Outer | No | ||
| Julie Cooper | Lab | Burnley | Aye | ||
| Justin Madders | Lab | Ellesmere Port and Bromborough | Aye | ||
| Justin Tomlinson | Con | North Swindon | No | ||
| Justine Greening | Con | Putney | No | ||
| Karin Smyth | Lab | Bristol South | Aye | ||
| Karl McCartney | Con | Lincoln | No | ||
| Karl Turner | Lab | Kingston upon Hull East | Aye | ||
| Kate Green | Lab | Stretford and Urmston | Aye | ||
| Kate Hollern | Lab | Blackburn | Aye | ||
| Keith Vaz | Lab | Leicester East | Aye | ||
| Kelly Tolhurst | Con | Rochester and Strood | No | ||
| Kelvin Hopkins | Lab | Luton North | Aye | ||
| Kevin Foster | Con | Torbay | No | ||
| Kevin Hollinrake | Con | Thirsk and Malton | No | ||
| Kirsten Oswald | SNP | East Renfrewshire | Aye | ||
| Kirsty Blackman | SNP | Aberdeen North | Aye | ||
| Kit Malthouse | Con | North West Hampshire | No | ||
| Kris Hopkins | Con | Keighley | No | ||
| Kwasi Kwarteng | Con | Spelthorne | No | ||
| Liz Kendall | Lab | Leicester West | Aye | ||
| Liz McInnes | Lab | Heywood and Middleton | Aye | ||
| Liz Saville Roberts | PC | Dwyfor Meirionnydd | Aye | ||
| Louise Haigh | Lab | Sheffield Heeley | Aye | ||
| Lucy Allan | Con | Telford | No | ||
| Lucy Frazer | Con | South East Cambridgeshire | No | ||
| Lucy Powell | Lab | Manchester Central | Aye | ||
| Luke Hall | Con | Thornbury and Yate | No | ||
| Maggie Throup | Con | Erewash | No | ||
| Margaret Ferrier | SNP | Rutherglen and Hamilton West | Aye | ||
| Margaret Greenwood | Lab | Wirral West | Aye | ||
| Margot James | Con | Stourbridge | No | ||
| Maria Caulfield | Con | Lewes | No | ||
| Maria Eagle | Lab | Liverpool Garston | Aye | ||
| Marion Fellows | SNP | Motherwell and Wishaw | Aye | ||
| Mark Durkan | SDLP | Foyle | Aye | ||
| Mark Pawsey | Con | Rugby | No | ||
| Mark Pritchard | Con | The Wrekin | No | ||
| Martin Docherty-Hughes | SNP | West Dunbartonshire | Aye | ||
| Martin Vickers | Con | Brigg and Immingham | No | ||
| Martyn Day | SNP | Linlithgow and East Falkirk | Aye | ||
| Mary Glindon | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend | Aye | ||
| Mary Robinson | Con | Cheadle | No | ||
| Matt Hancock | Con | West Suffolk | No | ||
| Matt Warman | Con | Boston and Skegness | No | ||
| Matthew Pennycook | Lab | Greenwich and Woolwich | Aye | ||
| Melanie Onn | Lab | Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes | Aye | ||
| Michael Dugher | Lab | Barnsley East | Aye | ||
| Michael Fabricant | Con | Lichfield | No | ||
| Michael Tomlinson | Con | Mid Dorset and North Poole | No | ||
| Michelle Donelan | Con | Chippenham | No | ||
| Michelle Thomson | Ind | Edinburgh West | Aye | ||
| Mike Freer | Con | Finchley and Golders Green | No | ||
| Mike Gapes | Lab | Ilford South | Aye | ||
| Mike Kane | Lab | Wythenshawe and Sale East | Aye | ||
| Mike Weir | SNP | Angus | Aye | ||
| Mims Davies | Con | East Grinstead and Uckfield | No | ||
| Mr Adrian Bailey | Lab | West Bromwich West | Aye | ||
| Mr Alistair Carmichael | LD | Orkney and Shetland | Aye | ||
| Mr Andrew Smith | Lab | Oxford East | Aye | ||
| Mr Andrew Turner | Con | Isle of Wight | No | ||
| Mr Barry Sheerman | Lab | Huddersfield | Aye | ||
| Mr Ben Bradshaw | Lab | Exeter | Aye | ||
| Mr Chris Leslie | Lab | Nottingham East | Aye | ||
| Mr Clive Betts | Lab | Sheffield South East | Aye | ||
| Mr David Burrowes | Con | Enfield, Southgate | No | ||
| Mr David Gauke | Con | South West Hertfordshire | No | ||
| Mr David Jones | Con | Clwyd West | No | ||
| Mr David Lammy | Lab | Tottenham | Aye | ||
| Mr David Nuttall | Con | Bury North | No | ||
| Mr David Winnick | Lab | Walsall North | Aye | ||
| Mr Dennis Skinner | Lab | Bolsover | Aye | ||
| Mr Dominic Grieve | Con | Beaconsfield | No | ||
| Mr George Osborne | Con | Tatton | No | ||
| Mr Iain Wright | Lab | Hartlepool | Aye | ||
| Mr Jim Cunningham | Lab | Coventry South | Aye | ||
| Mr Jonathan Djanogly | Con | Huntingdon | No | ||
| Mr Jonathan Lord | Con | Woking | No | ||
| Mr Keith Simpson | Con | Broadland | No | ||
| Mr Khalid Mahmood | Lab | Birmingham, Perry Barr | Aye | ||
| Mr Laurence Robertson | Con | Tewkesbury | No | ||
| Mr Marcus Fysh | Con | Yeovil | No | ||
| Mr Marcus Jones | Con | Nuneaton | No | ||
| Mr Mark Francois | Con | Rayleigh and Wickford | No | ||
| Mr Mark Williams | LD | Ceredigion | Aye | ||
| Mr Nicholas Brown | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne East | Aye | ||
| Mr Nick Hurd | Con | Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner | No | ||
| Mr Nigel Evans | Con | Ribble Valley | No | ||
| Mr Owen Paterson | Con | North Shropshire | No | ||
| Mr Peter Bone | Con | Wellingborough | No | ||
| Mr Philip Hollobone | Con | Kettering | No | ||
| Mr Ranil Jayawardena | Con | North East Hampshire | No | ||
| Mr Richard Bacon | Con | South Norfolk | No | ||
| Mr Rob Wilson | Con | Reading East | No | ||
| Mr Robin Walker | Con | Worcester | No | ||
| Mr Roger Godsiff | Lab | Birmingham, Hall Green | Aye | ||
| Mr Ronnie Campbell | Lab | Blyth Valley | Aye | ||
| Mr Sam Gyimah | Con | East Surrey | No | ||
| Mr Stephen Hepburn | Lab | Jarrow | Aye | ||
| Mr Steve Baker | Con | Wycombe | No | ||
| Mr Tobias Ellwood | Con | Bournemouth East | No | ||
| Mr Toby Perkins | Lab | Chesterfield | Aye | ||
| Mr Virendra Sharma | Lab | Ealing, Southall | Aye | ||
| Mr William Wragg | Con | Hazel Grove | No | ||
| Mrs Anne Main | Con | St Albans | No | ||
| Mrs Heather Wheeler | Con | South Derbyshire | No | ||
| Mrs Madeleine Moon | Lab | Bridgend | Aye | ||
| Mrs Pauline Latham | Con | Mid Derbyshire | No | ||
| Mrs Sharon Hodgson | Lab | Washington and Gateshead South | Aye | ||
| Mrs Sheryll Murray | Con | South East Cornwall | No | ||
| Ms Diane Abbott | Lab | Hackney North and Stoke Newington | Aye | ||
| Ms Marie Rimmer | Lab | St Helens South and Whiston | Aye | ||
| Ms Nadine Dorries | Con | Mid Bedfordshire | No | ||
| Ms Nusrat Ghani | Con | Sussex Weald | No | ||
| Ms Stella Creasy | Lab | Walthamstow | Aye | ||
| Nadhim Zahawi | Con | Stratford-on-Avon | No | ||
| Naz Shah | Lab | Bradford West | Aye | ||
| Neil Carmichael | Con | Stroud | No | ||
| Neil Parish | Con | Tiverton and Honiton | No | ||
| Nick Smith | Lab | Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney | Aye | ||
| Nigel Huddleston | Con | Droitwich and Evesham | No | ||
| Nigel Mills | Con | Amber Valley | No | ||
| Norman Lamb | LD | North Norfolk | Aye | ||
| Oliver Colvile | Con | Plymouth, Sutton and Devonport | No | ||
| Owen Smith | Lab | Pontypridd | Aye | ||
| Owen Thompson | SNP | Midlothian | Aye | ||
| Pat Glass | Lab | North West Durham | Aye | ||
| Pat McFadden | Lab | Wolverhampton South East | Aye | ||
| Patricia Gibson | SNP | North Ayrshire and Arran | Aye | ||
| Patrick Grady | SNP | Glasgow North | Aye | ||
| Paul Blomfield | Lab | Sheffield Central | Aye | ||
| Paul Flynn | Lab | Newport West | Aye | ||
| Paul Maynard | Con | Blackpool North and Cleveleys | No | ||
| Paul Scully | Con | Sutton and Cheam | No | ||
| Paula Sherriff | Lab | Dewsbury | Aye | ||
| Penny Mordaunt | Con | Portsmouth North | No | ||
| Peter Aldous | Con | Waveney | No | ||
| Peter Dowd | Lab | Bootle | Aye | ||
| Peter Grant | SNP | Glenrothes | Aye | ||
| Peter Heaton-Jones | Con | North Devon | No | ||
| Peter Kyle | Lab | Hove and Portslade | Aye | ||
| Philip Boswell | SNP | Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill | Aye | ||
| Philip Dunne | Con | Ludlow | No | ||
| Priti Patel | Con | Witham | No | ||
| Rachael Maskell | Lab | York Central | Aye | ||
| Rachel Reeves | Lab | Leeds West and Pudsey | Aye | ||
| Rebecca Harris | Con | Castle Point | No | ||
| Rebecca Long Bailey | Lab | Salford | Aye | ||
| Rebecca Pow | Con | Taunton Deane | No | ||
| Rehman Chishti | Con | Gillingham and Rainham | No | ||
| Richard Burden | Lab | Birmingham, Northfield | Aye | ||
| Richard Burgon | Lab | Leeds East | Aye | ||
| Richard Drax | Con | South Dorset | No | ||
| Richard Fuller | Con | North Bedfordshire | No | ||
| Richard Graham | Con | Gloucester | No | ||
| Rishi Sunak | Con | Richmond and Northallerton | No | ||
| Rob Marris | Lab | Wolverhampton South West | Aye | ||
| Robert Courts | Con | Witney | No | ||
| Robert Flello | Lab | Stoke-on-Trent South | Aye | ||
| Robert Halfon | Con | Harlow | No | ||
| Robert Jenrick | Con | Newark | No | ||
| Ronnie Cowan | SNP | Inverclyde | Aye | ||
| Rory Stewart | Con | Penrith and The Border | No | ||
| Rosie Cooper | Lab | West Lancashire | Aye | ||
| Royston Smith | Con | Southampton, Itchen | No | ||
| Sammy Wilson | DUP | East Antrim | No | ||
| Sarah Champion | Lab | Rotherham | Aye | ||
| Sarah Newton | Con | Truro and Falmouth | No | ||
| Sarah Olney | LD | Richmond Park | Aye | ||
| Scott Mann | Con | North Cornwall | No | ||
| Seema Kennedy | Con | South Ribble | No | ||
| Seema Malhotra | Lab | Feltham and Heston | Aye | ||
| Shabana Mahmood | Lab | Birmingham Ladywood | Aye | ||
| Shailesh Vara | Con | North West Cambridgeshire | No | ||
| Simon Hoare | Con | North Dorset | No | ||
| Simon Kirby | Con | Brighton, Kemptown | No | ||
| Sir Alan Campbell | Lab | Tynemouth | Aye | ||
| Sir Alan Duncan | Con | Rutland and Melton | No | ||
| Sir Alan Meale | Lab | Mansfield | Aye | ||
| Sir Alec Shelbrooke | Con | Wetherby and Easingwold | No | ||
| Sir Andrew Mitchell | Con | Sutton Coldfield | No | ||
| Sir Bernard Jenkin | Con | Harwich and North Essex | No | ||
| Sir Bill Wiggin | Con | North Herefordshire | No | ||
| Sir Brandon Lewis | Con | Great Yarmouth | No | ||
| Sir Charles Walker | Con | Broxbourne | No | ||
| Sir Christopher Chope | Con | Christchurch | No | ||
| Sir Conor Burns | Con | Bournemouth West | No | ||
| Sir David Amess | Con | Southend West | No | ||
| Sir David Crausby | Lab | Bolton North East | Aye | ||
| Sir David Evennett | Con | Bexleyheath and Crayford | No | ||
| Sir David Lidington | Con | Aylesbury | No | ||
| Sir Desmond Swayne | Con | New Forest West | No | ||
| Sir Gary Streeter | Con | South West Devon | No | ||
| Sir Gavin Williamson | Con | Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge | No | ||
| Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown | Con | North Cotswolds | No | ||
| Sir Geoffrey Cox | Con | Torridge and Tavistock | No | ||
| Sir George Hollingbery | Con | Meon Valley | No | ||
| Sir George Howarth | Lab | Knowsley | Aye | ||
| Sir Gerald Howarth | Con | Aldershot | No | ||
| Sir Iain Duncan Smith | Con | Chingford and Woodford Green | No | ||
| Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg | Con | North East Somerset | No | ||
| Sir James Cleverly | Con | Braintree | No | ||
| Sir James Duddridge | Con | Rochford and Southend East | No | ||
| Sir Jeremy Quin | Con | Horsham | No | ||
| Sir Jeremy Wright | Con | Kenilworth and Southam | No | ||
| Sir Julian Brazier | Con | Canterbury | No | ||
| Sir Julian Lewis | Con | New Forest East | No | ||
| Sir Julian Smith | Con | Skipton and Ripon | No | ||
| Sir Liam Fox | Con | North Somerset | No | ||
| Sir Mark Hendrick | Lab | Preston | Aye | ||
| Sir Mark Spencer | Con | Sherwood | No | ||
| Sir Mel Stride | Con | Central Devon | No | ||
| Sir Michael Ellis | Con | Northampton North | No | ||
| Sir Michael Fallon | Con | Sevenoaks | No | ||
| Sir Mike Penning | Con | Hemel Hempstead | No | ||
| Sir Nicholas Dakin | Lab | Scunthorpe | Aye | ||
| Sir Oliver Dowden | Con | Hertsmere | No | ||
| Sir Oliver Heald | Con | North East Hertfordshire | No | ||
| Sir Oliver Letwin | Con | West Dorset | No | ||
| Sir Paul Beresford | Con | Mole Valley | No | ||
| Sir Peter Bottomley | Con | Worthing West | No | ||
| Sir Philip Davies | Con | Shipley | No | ||
| Sir Robert Buckland | Con | South Swindon | No | ||
| Sir Robert Goodwill | Con | Scarborough and Whitby | No | ||
| Sir Robert Neill | Con | Bromley and Chislehurst | No | ||
| Sir Robert Syms | Con | Poole | No | ||
| Sir Roger Gale | Con | Herne Bay and Sandwich | No | ||
| Sir Sajid Javid | Con | Bromsgrove | No | ||
| Sir Simon Burns | Con | Chelmsford | No | ||
| Sir Stephen Timms | Lab | East Ham | Aye | ||
| Sir William Cash | Con | Stone | No | ||
| Stephen Crabb | Con | Preseli Pembrokeshire | No | ||
| Stephen Gethins | SNP | Arbroath and Broughty Ferry | Aye | ||
| Stephen Kinnock | Lab | Aberafan Maesteg | Aye | ||
| Stephen McPartland | Con | Stevenage | No | ||
| Stephen Metcalfe | Con | South Basildon and East Thurrock | No | ||
| Steve Barclay | Con | North East Cambridgeshire | No | ||
| Steve Brine | Con | Winchester | No | ||
| Steve Double | Con | St Austell and Newquay | No | ||
| Steve Reed | Lab | Streatham and Croydon North | Aye | ||
| Steve Rotheram | Lab | Liverpool, Walton | Aye | ||
| Steven Paterson | SNP | Stirling | Aye | ||
| Stewart Hosie | SNP | Dundee East | Aye | ||
| Stuart Andrew | Con | Daventry | No | ||
| Stuart Blair Donaldson | SNP | West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine | Aye | ||
| Stuart C McDonald | SNP | Cumbernauld, Kilsyth and Kirkintilloch East | Aye | ||
| Suella Braverman | Con | Fareham and Waterlooville | No | ||
| Susan Elan Jones | Lab | Clwyd South | Aye | ||
| Teresa Pearce | Lab | Erith and Thamesmead | Aye | ||
| Theresa Villiers | Con | Chipping Barnet | No | ||
| Tim Farron | LD | Westmorland and Lonsdale | Aye | ||
| Tim Loughton | Con | East Worthing and Shoreham | No | ||
| Tom Brake | LD | Carshalton and Wallington | Aye | ||
| Tom Pursglove | Con | Corby | No | ||
| Tom Tugendhat | Con | Tonbridge | No | ||
| Tommy Sheppard | SNP | Edinburgh East | Aye | ||
| Tracy Brabin | Lab | Batley and Spen | Aye | ||
| Trudy Harrison | Con | Copeland | No | ||
| Tulip Siddiq | Lab | Hampstead and Highgate | Aye | ||
| Valerie Vaz | Lab | Walsall and Bloxwich | Aye | ||
| Vicky Foxcroft | Lab | Lewisham North | Aye | ||
| Victoria Atkins | Con | Louth and Horncastle | No | ||
| Victoria Borwick | Con | Kensington | No | ||
| Wayne David | Lab | Caerphilly | Aye | ||
| Wendy Morton | Con | Aldridge-Brownhills | No | ||
| Wes Streeting | Lab | Ilford North | Aye | ||
| Will Quince | Con | Colchester | No | ||
| Yasmin Qureshi | Lab | Bolton South and Walkden | Aye | ||
| Yvette Cooper | Lab | Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley | Aye | ||
| Yvonne Fovargue | Lab | Makerfield | Aye | ||
| Alison Thewliss | SNP | Glasgow Central | — | ||
| Alun Cairns | Con | Vale of Glamorgan | — | ||
| Andrew Bingham | Con | High Peak | — | ||
| Angela Crawley | SNP | Lanark and Hamilton East | — | ||
| Anne McLaughlin | SNP | Glasgow North East | — | ||
| Anne-Marie Trevelyan | Con | Berwick-upon-Tweed | — | ||
| Carol Monaghan | SNP | Glasgow North West | — | ||
| Caroline Lucas | Green | Brighton, Pavilion | — | ||
| Charlie Elphicke | Ind | Dover | — | ||
| Chloe Smith | Con | Norwich North | — | ||
| Chris Elmore | Lab | Bridgend | — | ||
| Chris Evans | Lab | Caerphilly | — | ||
| Chris Ruane | Lab | Vale of Clwyd | — | ||
| Chris Williamson | Ind | Derby North | — | ||
| Christina Rees | Lab | Neath | — | ||
| Chuka Umunna | LD | Streatham | — | ||
| Dame Andrea Jenkyns | Con | Morley and Outwood | — | ||
| Dame Angela Eagle | Lab | Wallasey | — | ||
| Dame Angela Watkinson | Con | Hornchurch and Upminster | — | ||
| Dame Karen Bradley | Con | Staffordshire Moorlands | — | ||
| Damian Collins | Con | Folkestone and Hythe | — | ||
| Damian Green | Con | Ashford | — | ||
| David Davis | Con | Goole and Pocklington | — | ||
| David Mackintosh | Con | Northampton South | — | ||
| David Simpson | DUP | Upper Bann | — | ||
| Dr Matthew Offord | Con | Hendon | — | ||
| Dr Philippa Whitford | SNP | Central Ayrshire | — | ||
| Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods | Lab | City of Durham | — | ||
| Ed Davey | LD | Kingston and Surbiton | — | ||
| Ed Miliband | Lab | Doncaster North | — | ||
| Emma Reynolds | Lab | Wycombe | — | ||
| Fabian Hamilton | Lab | Leeds North East | — | ||
| Fiona Bruce | Con | Congleton | — | ||
| Gareth Thomas | Lab | Harrow West | — | ||
| Geraint Davies | Ind | Swansea West | — | ||
| Grahame Morris | Lab | Easington | — | ||
| Guto Bebb | Ind | Aberconwy | — | ||
| Helen Jones | Lab | Warrington North | — | ||
| Ian C. Lucas | Lab | Wrexham | — | ||
| Jack Lopresti | Con | Filton and Bradley Stoke | — | ||
| James Brokenshire | Con | Old Bexley and Sidcup | — | ||
| James Gray | Con | North Wiltshire | — | ||
| Jeremy Corbyn | YP | Islington North | — | ||
| Jessica Morden | Lab | Newport East | — | ||
| Jo Stevens | Lab | Cardiff East | — | ||
| Jo Swinson | LD | East Dunbartonshire | — | ||
| Joan Ryan | IGC | Enfield North | — | ||
| John McNally | SNP | Falkirk | — | ||
| John Nicolson | SNP | Ochil and South Perthshire | — | ||
| Julian Knight | Ind | Solihull | — | ||
| Karen Lumley | Con | Redditch | — | ||
| Kate Osamor | Lab | Edmonton and Winchmore Hill | — | ||
| Kerry McCarthy | Lab | Bristol East | — | ||
| Lady Hermon | Ind | North Down | — | ||
| Liam Byrne | Lab | Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North | — | ||
| Lilian Greenwood | Lab | Nottingham South | — | ||
| Lisa Nandy | Lab | Wigan | — | ||
| Mark Field | Con | Cities of London and Westminster | — | ||
| Mark Garnier | Con | Wyre Forest | — | ||
| Mark Menzies | Ind | Fylde | — | ||
| Mary Creagh | Lab | Coventry East | — | ||
| Mhairi Black | SNP | Paisley and Renfrewshire South | — | ||
| Mike Wood | Con | Kingswinford and South Staffordshire | — | ||
| Mr Ben Wallace | Con | Wyre and Preston North | — | ||
| Mr David Anderson | Lab | Blaydon | — | ||
| Mr Douglas Carswell | Ind | Clacton | — | ||
| Mr Gavin Shuker | Ind | Luton South | — | ||
| Mr Geoffrey Robinson | Lab | Coventry North West | — | ||
| Mr Graham Allen | Lab | Nottingham North | — | ||
| Mr Gregory Campbell | DUP | East Londonderry | — | ||
| Mr Ian Liddell-Grainger | Con | Bridgwater and West Somerset | — | ||
| Mr Ivan Lewis | Ind | Bury South | — | ||
| Mr John Baron | Con | Basildon and Billericay | — | ||
| Mr Mark Prisk | Con | Hertford and Stortford | — | ||
| Mr Nick Clegg | LD | Sheffield, Hallam | — | ||
| Mrs Flick Drummond | Con | Meon Valley | — | ||
| Ms Karen Buck | Lab | Westminster North | — | ||
| Ms Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh | SNP | Ochil and South Perthshire | — | ||
| Natalie McGarry | Ind | Glasgow East | — | ||
| Neil Coyle | Lab | Bermondsey and Old Southwark | — | ||
| Neil Gray | SNP | Airdrie and Shotts | — | ||
| Nick Boles | Ind | Grantham and Stamford | — | ||
| Nick Gibb | Con | Bognor Regis and Littlehampton | — | ||
| Nick Thomas-Symonds | Lab | Torfaen | — | ||
| Nigel Adams | Con | Selby and Ainsty | — | ||
| Paul Farrelly | Lab | Newcastle-under-Lyme | — | ||
| Paul Maskey | SF | Belfast West | — | ||
| Pete Wishart | SNP | Perth and Kinross-shire | — | ||
| Richard Arkless | SNP | Dumfries and Galloway | — | ||
| Roger Mullin | SNP | Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath | — | ||
| Rushanara Ali | Lab | Bethnal Green and Stepney | — | ||
| Ruth Cadbury | Lab | Brentford and Isleworth | — | ||
| Simon Danczuk | Ind | Rochdale | — | ||
| Sir Edward Leigh | Con | Gainsborough | — | ||
| Sir Greg Knight | Con | East Yorkshire | — | ||
| Sir Jake Berry | Con | Rossendale and Darwen | — | ||
| Sir Jeffrey M Donaldson | Ind | Lagan Valley | — | ||
| Sir Jeremy Hunt | Con | Godalming and Ash | — | ||
| Sir John Hayes | Con | South Holland and The Deepings | — | ||
| Sir John Whittingdale | Con | Maldon | — | ||
| Sir Keir Starmer | Lab | Holborn and St Pancras | — | ||
| Sir Kevin Barron | Lab | Rother Valley | — | ||
| Sir Lindsay Hoyle | Spk | Chorley | — | ||
| Sir Mark Tami | Lab | Alyn and Deeside | — | ||
| Sir Vince Cable | LD | Twickenham | — | ||
| Stephen Doughty | Lab | Cardiff South and Penarth | — | ||
| Stephen Hammond | Con | Wimbledon | — | ||
| Stephen Lloyd | LD | Eastbourne | — | ||
| Stephen Pound | Lab | Ealing North | — | ||
| Stephen Twigg | Lab | Liverpool, West Derby | — | ||
| Stewart Malcolm McDonald | SNP | Glasgow South | — | ||
| Tom Blenkinsop | Lab | Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland | — |
FAQs
What was the result of this Commons division?
This division was rejected, with 230 Ayes and 289 Noes. Source
What is a Commons division?
A Commons division is a recorded vote in the House of Commons where MPs are recorded as voting Aye or No. Source
How many MPs voted in this division?
471 MPs have an imported recorded vote for this division. Source
What does did not vote mean on this division?
Did not vote means there is no imported Aye or No vote for that MP in this division. It does not by itself explain the reason. Source
What does rebel mean on this division?
Rebel means the MP's recorded vote differed from the majority recorded vote of their party in this division. Independent and Speaker roles are not labelled as rebels because they do not have a party whip. Source
What does party position mean on this division?
Party position is the direction the majority of a party's voting members took in this division — Aye or No. Parliament does not publish official whipping instructions, so this is derived from the recorded votes rather than from a stated whip. Source
Where does this division data come from?
This division and its vote records come from the Commons Votes API. Source
What bill is this division about?
This division has not been linked to a specific bill. Not all divisions relate to bills — some are Opposition Day motions, procedural votes, or other business. Source