Division 10 · 4 September 2024
Budget Responsibility Bill: Committee: Amendment 9
Government Bill
Tax
At a glance
This division was rejected on 4 September 2024 by a margin of 257, with 109 Ayes and 366 Noes. The largest Aye bloc was Conservative with 107 votes. The largest No bloc was Labour with 360 votes. This motion was proposed by Nigel Huddleston. This division took place during a debate on Budget Responsibility Bill. This division is linked to the Budget Responsibility Act 2024 (Government Bill).
109
Ayes
366
Noes
Rejected
Result
478
Voted
Rejected by 257
Ayes 109 / Noes 366
Bill context
The motion
Proposed by Nigel Huddleston
I beg to move amendment 9, page 1, line 14, at end insert— “(c) or any changes to the government’s fiscal targets.” This amendment requires the OBR to produce and publish a section 4(3) report at the time new fiscal rules are announced by the Treasury.
Party breakdown
Click a row to filter votes below by that party.
| Party | Party position | Ayes | Noes | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lab Labour | Voted No | 0 | 360 | 397 |
| Con Conservative | Voted Aye | 107 | 0 | 121 |
| Ind Independent | No party whip | 1 | 7 | 17 |
| DUP Democratic Unionist Party | Voted Aye | 2 | 0 | 5 |
| SDLP Social Democratic & Labour Party | Voted No | 0 | 1 | 2 |
| LD Liberal Democrat | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 71 |
| SNP Scottish National Party | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 9 |
| SF Sinn Féin | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 7 |
| Lab Labour (Co-op) | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 5 |
| Green Green Party | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 4 |
| PC Plaid Cymru | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 4 |
| RUK Reform UK | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 3 |
| TUV Traditional Unionist Voice | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| APNI Alliance | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| Spk Speaker | No party whip | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| RB Restore Britain | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| UUP Ulster Unionist Party | No clear majority | 0 | 0 | 1 |
"Party position" is how the majority of each party's voting members voted in this division. Parliament does not publish official whipping instructions, so this is derived from the recorded votes. "Rebels" are members who voted against their party's majority; Independent and Speaker roles have no party whip.
Individual votes
| Compare | MP | Party | Constituency | Vote | Rebel |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abtisam Mohamed | Lab | Sheffield Central | No | ||
| Adam Jogee | Lab | Newcastle-under-Lyme | No | ||
| Adam Thompson | Lab | Erewash | No | ||
| Afzal Khan | Lab | Manchester Rusholme | No | ||
| Al Carns | Lab | Birmingham Selly Oak | No | ||
| Alan Gemmell | Lab | Central Ayrshire | No | ||
| Alan Mak | Con | Havant | Aye | ||
| Alan Strickland | Lab | Newton Aycliffe and Spennymoor | No | ||
| Alberto Costa | Con | South Leicestershire | Aye | ||
| Alex Baker | Lab | Aldershot | No | ||
| Alex Ballinger | Lab | Halesowen | No | ||
| Alex Burghart | Con | Brentwood and Ongar | Aye | ||
| Alex Davies-Jones | Lab | Pontypridd | No | ||
| Alex Mayer | Lab | Dunstable and Leighton Buzzard | No | ||
| Alex McIntyre | Lab | Gloucester | No | ||
| Alex Norris | Lab | Nottingham North and Kimberley | No | ||
| Alice Macdonald | Lab | Norwich North | No | ||
| Alicia Kearns | Con | Rutland and Stamford | Aye | ||
| Alison Griffiths | Con | Bognor Regis and Littlehampton | Aye | ||
| Alison Hume | Lab | Scarborough and Whitby | No | ||
| Alison McGovern | Lab | Birkenhead | No | ||
| Alison Taylor | Lab | Paisley and Renfrewshire North | No | ||
| Alistair Strathern | Lab | Hitchin | No | ||
| Amanda Hack | Lab | North West Leicestershire | No | ||
| Amanda Martin | Lab | Portsmouth North | No | ||
| Andrew Bowie | Con | West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine | Aye | ||
| Andrew Cooper | Lab | Mid Cheshire | No | ||
| Andrew Griffith | Con | Arundel and South Downs | Aye | ||
| Andrew Gwynne | Lab | Gorton and Denton | No | ||
| Andrew Lewin | Lab | Welwyn Hatfield | No | ||
| Andrew Pakes | Lab | Peterborough | No | ||
| Andrew Ranger | Lab | Wrexham | No | ||
| Andrew Rosindell | Con | Romford | Aye | ||
| Andrew Western | Lab | Stretford and Urmston | No | ||
| Andy MacNae | Lab | Rossendale and Darwen | No | ||
| Andy McDonald | Lab | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East | No | ||
| Andy Slaughter | Lab | Hammersmith and Chiswick | No | ||
| Anna Dixon | Lab | Shipley | No | ||
| Anna Gelderd | Lab | South East Cornwall | No | ||
| Anna McMorrin | Lab | Cardiff North | No | ||
| Anna Turley | Lab | Redcar | No | ||
| Anneliese Dodds | Lab | Oxford East | No | ||
| Anneliese Midgley | Lab | Knowsley | No | ||
| Antonia Bance | Lab | Tipton and Wednesbury | No | ||
| Aphra Brandreth | Con | Chester South and Eddisbury | Aye | ||
| Apsana Begum | Ind | Poplar and Limehouse | No | ||
| Ashley Dalton | Lab | West Lancashire | No | ||
| Baggy Shanker | Lab | Derby South | No | ||
| Bambos Charalambous | Lab | Southgate and Wood Green | No | ||
| Barry Gardiner | Lab | Brent West | No | ||
| Becky Gittins | Lab | Clwyd East | No | ||
| Ben Coleman | Lab | Chelsea and Fulham | No | ||
| Ben Goldsborough | Lab | South Norfolk | No | ||
| Ben Obese-Jecty | Con | Huntingdon | Aye | ||
| Bill Esterson | Lab | Sefton Central | No | ||
| Blair McDougall | Lab | East Renfrewshire | No | ||
| Blake Stephenson | Con | Mid Bedfordshire | Aye | ||
| Bob Blackman | Con | Harrow East | Aye | ||
| Bradley Thomas | Con | Bromsgrove | Aye | ||
| Brian Leishman | Lab | Alloa and Grangemouth | No | ||
| Callum Anderson | Lab | Buckingham and Bletchley | No | ||
| Cat Smith | Lab | Lancaster and Wyre | No | ||
| Catherine Atkinson | Lab | Derby North | No | ||
| Catherine Fookes | Lab | Monmouthshire | No | ||
| Catherine McKinnell | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne North | No | ||
| Catherine West | Lab | Hornsey and Friern Barnet | No | ||
| Charlie Dewhirst | Con | Bridlington and The Wolds | Aye | ||
| Charlotte Nichols | Lab | Warrington North | No | ||
| Chris Curtis | Lab | Milton Keynes North | No | ||
| Chris Elmore | Lab | Bridgend | No | ||
| Chris Hinchliff | Lab | North East Hertfordshire | No | ||
| Chris Kane | Lab | Stirling and Strathallan | No | ||
| Chris McDonald | Lab | Stockton North | No | ||
| Chris Murray | Lab | Edinburgh East and Musselburgh | No | ||
| Chris Philp | Con | Croydon South | Aye | ||
| Chris Vince | Lab | Harlow | No | ||
| Chris Ward | Lab | Brighton Kemptown and Peacehaven | No | ||
| Chris Webb | Lab | Blackpool South | No | ||
| Christian Wakeford | Lab | Bury South | No | ||
| Claire Coutinho | Con | East Surrey | Aye | ||
| Claire Hazelgrove | Lab | Filton and Bradley Stoke | No | ||
| Claire Hughes | Lab | Bangor Aberconwy | No | ||
| Clive Efford | Lab | Eltham and Chislehurst | No | ||
| Clive Lewis | Lab | Norwich South | No | ||
| Colum Eastwood | SDLP | Foyle | No | ||
| Connor Naismith | Lab | Crewe and Nantwich | No | ||
| Dame Angela Eagle | Lab | Wallasey | No | ||
| Dame Caroline Dinenage | Con | Gosport | Aye | ||
| Dame Chi Onwurah | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West | No | ||
| Dame Diana Johnson | Lab | Kingston upon Hull North and Cottingham | No | ||
| Dame Harriett Baldwin | Con | West Worcestershire | Aye | ||
| Dame Karen Bradley | Con | Staffordshire Moorlands | Aye | ||
| Dame Meg Hillier | Lab | Hackney South and Shoreditch | No | ||
| Dame Nia Griffith | Lab | Llanelli | No | ||
| Dame Siobhain McDonagh | Lab | Mitcham and Morden | No | ||
| Damian Hinds | Con | East Hampshire | Aye | ||
| Damien Egan | Lab | Bristol North East | No | ||
| Dan Aldridge | Lab | Weston-super-Mare | No | ||
| Dan Carden | Lab | Liverpool Walton | No | ||
| Dan Tomlinson | Lab | Chipping Barnet | No | ||
| Daniel Francis | Lab | Bexleyheath and Crayford | No | ||
| Daniel Zeichner | Lab | Cambridge | No | ||
| Danny Beales | Lab | Uxbridge and South Ruislip | No | ||
| Danny Kruger | Con | East Wiltshire | Aye | ||
| Darren Jones | Lab | Bristol North West | No | ||
| Darren Paffey | Lab | Southampton Itchen | No | ||
| Dave Robertson | Lab | Lichfield | No | ||
| David Baines | Lab | St Helens North | No | ||
| David Burton-Sampson | Lab | Southend West and Leigh | No | ||
| David Davis | Con | Goole and Pocklington | Aye | ||
| David Mundell | Con | Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale | Aye | ||
| David Pinto-Duschinsky | Lab | Hendon | No | ||
| David Reed | Con | Exmouth and Exeter East | Aye | ||
| David Simmonds | Con | Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner | Aye | ||
| David Smith | Lab | North Northumberland | No | ||
| David Taylor | Lab | Hemel Hempstead | No | ||
| Dawn Butler | Lab | Brent East | No | ||
| Debbie Abrahams | Lab | Oldham East and Saddleworth | No | ||
| Deirdre Costigan | Lab | Ealing Southall | No | ||
| Derek Twigg | Lab | Widnes and Halewood | No | ||
| Douglas McAllister | Lab | West Dunbartonshire | No | ||
| Dr Allison Gardner | Lab | Stoke-on-Trent South | No | ||
| Dr Andrew Murrison | Con | South West Wiltshire | Aye | ||
| Dr Beccy Cooper | Lab | Worthing West | No | ||
| Dr Ben Spencer | Con | Runnymede and Weybridge | Aye | ||
| Dr Caroline Johnson | Con | Sleaford and North Hykeham | Aye | ||
| Dr Jeevun Sandher | Lab | Loughborough | No | ||
| Dr Kieran Mullan | Con | Bexhill and Battle | Aye | ||
| Dr Lauren Sullivan | Lab | Gravesham | No | ||
| Dr Luke Evans | Con | Hinckley and Bosworth | Aye | ||
| Dr Marie Tidball | Lab | Penistone and Stocksbridge | No | ||
| Dr Neil Hudson | Con | Epping Forest | Aye | ||
| Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst | Con | Solihull West and Shirley | Aye | ||
| Dr Peter Prinsley | Lab | Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket | No | ||
| Dr Rupa Huq | Lab | Ealing Central and Acton | No | ||
| Dr Scott Arthur | Lab | Edinburgh South West | No | ||
| Dr Simon Opher | Lab | Stroud | No | ||
| Dr Zubir Ahmed | Lab | Glasgow South West | No | ||
| Edward Argar | Con | Melton and Syston | Aye | ||
| Elaine Stewart | Lab | Ayr, Carrick and Cumnock | No | ||
| Ellie Reeves | Lab | Lewisham West and East Dulwich | No | ||
| Emily Darlington | Lab | Milton Keynes Central | No | ||
| Emily Thornberry | Lab | Islington South and Finsbury | No | ||
| Emma Foody | Lab | Cramlington and Killingworth | No | ||
| Emma Hardy | Lab | Kingston upon Hull West and Haltemprice | No | ||
| Emma Lewell | Lab | South Shields | No | ||
| Emma Reynolds | Lab | Wycombe | No | ||
| Euan Stainbank | Lab | Falkirk | No | ||
| Fabian Hamilton | Lab | Leeds North East | No | ||
| Feryal Clark | Lab | Enfield North | No | ||
| Fleur Anderson | Lab | Putney | No | ||
| Florence Eshalomi | Lab | Vauxhall and Camberwell Green | No | ||
| Frank McNally | Lab | Coatbridge and Bellshill | No | ||
| Fred Thomas | Lab | Plymouth Moor View | No | ||
| Gareth Bacon | Con | Orpington | Aye | ||
| Gareth Davies | Con | Grantham and Bourne | Aye | ||
| Gareth Snell | Lab | Stoke-on-Trent Central | No | ||
| Gareth Thomas | Lab | Harrow West | No | ||
| Gavin Robinson | DUP | Belfast East | Aye | ||
| Gen Kitchen | Lab | Wellingborough and Rushden | No | ||
| George Freeman | Con | Mid Norfolk | Aye | ||
| Georgia Gould | Lab | Queen's Park and Maida Vale | No | ||
| Gerald Jones | Lab | Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare | No Teller | ||
| Gill Furniss | Lab | Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough | No | ||
| Gill German | Lab | Clwyd North | No | ||
| Gordon McKee | Lab | Glasgow South | No | ||
| Graeme Downie | Lab | Dunfermline and Dollar | No | ||
| Graham Stringer | Lab | Blackley and Middleton South | No | ||
| Graham Stuart | Con | Beverley and Holderness | Aye | ||
| Grahame Morris | Lab | Easington | No | ||
| Greg Smith | Con | Mid Buckinghamshire | Aye | ||
| Gregor Poynton | Lab | Livingston | No | ||
| Gregory Stafford | Con | Farnham and Bordon | Aye | ||
| Gurinder Singh Josan | Lab | Smethwick | No | ||
| Harpreet Uppal | Lab | Huddersfield | No | ||
| Harriet Cross | Con | Gordon and Buchan | Aye | ||
| Heidi Alexander | Lab | Swindon South | No | ||
| Helen Hayes | Lab | Dulwich and West Norwood | No | ||
| Helen Whately | Con | Faversham and Mid Kent | Aye | ||
| Helena Dollimore | Lab | Hastings and Rye | No | ||
| Henry Tufnell | Lab | Mid and South Pembrokeshire | No | ||
| Hilary Benn | Lab | Leeds South | No | ||
| Ian Lavery | Lab | Blyth and Ashington | No | ||
| Ian Murray | Lab | Edinburgh South | No | ||
| Imogen Walker | Lab | Hamilton and Clyde Valley | No | ||
| Imran Hussain | Ind | Bradford East | No | ||
| Iqbal Mohamed | Ind | Dewsbury and Batley | Aye | ||
| Irene Campbell | Lab | North Ayrshire and Arran | No | ||
| Jack Abbott | Lab | Ipswich | No | ||
| Jack Rankin | Con | Windsor | Aye | ||
| Jacob Collier | Lab | Burton and Uttoxeter | No | ||
| Jade Botterill | Lab | Ossett and Denby Dale | No | ||
| Jake Richards | Lab | Rother Valley | No | ||
| James Asser | Lab | West Ham and Beckton | No | ||
| James Cartlidge | Con | South Suffolk | Aye | ||
| James Murray | Lab | Ealing North | No | ||
| James Naish | Lab | Rushcliffe | No | ||
| James Wild | Con | North West Norfolk | Aye | ||
| Jas Athwal | Lab | Ilford South | No | ||
| Jayne Kirkham | Lab | Truro and Falmouth | No | ||
| Jeff Smith | Lab | Manchester Withington | No | ||
| Jen Craft | Lab | Thurrock | No | ||
| Jenny Riddell-Carpenter | Lab | Suffolk Coastal | No | ||
| Jeremy Corbyn | Ind | Islington North | No | ||
| Jerome Mayhew | Con | Broadland and Fakenham | Aye | ||
| Jess Asato | Lab | Lowestoft | No | ||
| Jess Phillips | Lab | Birmingham Yardley | No | ||
| Jessica Morden | Lab | Newport East | No | ||
| Jessica Toale | Lab | Bournemouth West | No | ||
| Jim Dickson | Lab | Dartford | No | ||
| Jim McMahon | Lab | Oldham West, Chadderton and Royton | No | ||
| Jim Shannon | DUP | Strangford | Aye | ||
| Jo Platt | Lab | Leigh and Atherton | No | ||
| Jo Stevens | Lab | Cardiff East | No | ||
| Jo White | Lab | Bassetlaw | No | ||
| Joani Reid | Lab | East Kilbride and Strathaven | No | ||
| Jodie Gosling | Lab | Nuneaton | No | ||
| Joe Morris | Lab | Hexham | No | ||
| Joe Robertson | Con | Isle of Wight East | Aye | ||
| Johanna Baxter | Lab | Paisley and Renfrewshire South | No | ||
| John Cooper | Con | Dumfries and Galloway | Aye | ||
| John Glen | Con | Salisbury | Aye | ||
| John Grady | Lab | Glasgow East | No | ||
| John Healey | Lab | Rawmarsh and Conisbrough | No | ||
| John Lamont | Con | Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk | Aye | ||
| John McDonnell | Ind | Hayes and Harlington | No | ||
| John Slinger | Lab | Rugby | No | ||
| John Whitby | Lab | Derbyshire Dales | No | ||
| Jon Pearce | Lab | High Peak | No | ||
| Jon Trickett | Lab | Normanton and Hemsworth | No | ||
| Jonathan Davies | Lab | Mid Derbyshire | No | ||
| Jonathan Hinder | Lab | Pendle and Clitheroe | No | ||
| Josh Dean | Lab | Hertford and Stortford | No | ||
| Josh Fenton-Glynn | Lab | Calder Valley | No | ||
| Josh MacAlister | Lab | Whitehaven and Workington | No | ||
| Josh Newbury | Lab | Cannock Chase | No | ||
| Josh Simons | Lab | Makerfield | No | ||
| Joy Morrissey | Con | Beaconsfield | Aye | ||
| Julia Buckley | Lab | Shrewsbury | No | ||
| Julia Lopez | Con | Hornchurch and Upminster | Aye | ||
| Juliet Campbell | Lab | Broxtowe | No | ||
| Justin Madders | Lab | Ellesmere Port and Bromborough | No | ||
| Kanishka Narayan | Lab | Vale of Glamorgan | No | ||
| Karin Smyth | Lab | Bristol South | No | ||
| Karl Turner | Lab | Kingston upon Hull East | No | ||
| Kate Dearden | Lab | Halifax | No | ||
| Kate Osamor | Lab | Edmonton and Winchmore Hill | No | ||
| Kate Osborne | Lab | Jarrow and Gateshead East | No | ||
| Katie Lam | Con | Weald of Kent | Aye | ||
| Katie White | Lab | Leeds North West | No | ||
| Katrina Murray | Lab | Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch | No | ||
| Keir Mather | Lab | Selby | No Teller | ||
| Kevin Bonavia | Lab | Stevenage | No | ||
| Kevin Hollinrake | Con | Thirsk and Malton | Aye | ||
| Kevin McKenna | Lab | Sittingbourne and Sheppey | No | ||
| Kim Johnson | Lab | Liverpool Riverside | No | ||
| Kim Leadbeater | Lab | Spen Valley | No | ||
| Kirith Entwistle | Lab | Bolton North East | No | ||
| Kirsteen Sullivan | Lab | Bathgate and Linlithgow | No | ||
| Kirsty McNeill | Lab | Midlothian | No | ||
| Kit Malthouse | Con | North West Hampshire | Aye | ||
| Laura Kyrke-Smith | Lab | Aylesbury | No | ||
| Lauren Edwards | Lab | Rochester and Strood | No | ||
| Laurence Turner | Lab | Birmingham Northfield | No | ||
| Lee Barron | Lab | Corby and East Northamptonshire | No | ||
| Lee Pitcher | Lab | Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme | No | ||
| Leigh Ingham | Lab | Stafford | No | ||
| Lewis Atkinson | Lab | Sunderland Central | No | ||
| Lewis Cocking | Con | Broxbourne | Aye | ||
| Liam Byrne | Lab | Birmingham Hodge Hill and Solihull North | No | ||
| Liam Conlon | Lab | Beckenham and Penge | No | ||
| Lilian Greenwood | Lab | Nottingham South | No | ||
| Lillian Jones | Lab | Kilmarnock and Loudoun | No | ||
| Lincoln Jopp | Con | Spelthorne | Aye | ||
| Linsey Farnsworth | Lab | Amber Valley | No | ||
| Liz Kendall | Lab | Leicester West | No | ||
| Liz Twist | Lab | Blaydon and Consett | No | ||
| Lizzi Collinge | Lab | Morecambe and Lunesdale | No | ||
| Lloyd Hatton | Lab | South Dorset | No | ||
| Lola McEvoy | Lab | Darlington | No | ||
| Louise Haigh | Lab | Sheffield Heeley | No | ||
| Louise Sandher-Jones | Lab | North East Derbyshire | No | ||
| Lucy Powell | Lab | Manchester Central | No | ||
| Lucy Rigby | Lab | Northampton North | No | ||
| Luke Akehurst | Lab | North Durham | No | ||
| Luke Murphy | Lab | Basingstoke | No | ||
| Luke Myer | Lab | Middlesbrough South and East Cleveland | No | ||
| Luke Pollard | Lab | Plymouth Sutton and Devonport | No | ||
| Margaret Mullane | Lab | Dagenham and Rainham | No | ||
| Maria Eagle | Lab | Liverpool Garston | No | ||
| Mark Ferguson | Lab | Gateshead Central and Whickham | No | ||
| Mark Garnier | Con | Wyre Forest | Aye | ||
| Mark Pritchard | Con | The Wrekin | Aye | ||
| Mark Sewards | Lab | Leeds South West and Morley | No | ||
| Markus Campbell-Savours | Lab | Penrith and Solway | No | ||
| Marsha De Cordova | Lab | Battersea | No | ||
| Martin McCluskey | Lab | Inverclyde and Renfrewshire West | No | ||
| Martin Rhodes | Lab | Glasgow North | No | ||
| Martin Vickers | Con | Brigg and Immingham | Aye | ||
| Mary Glindon | Lab | Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend | No | ||
| Matt Bishop | Lab | Forest of Dean | No | ||
| Matt Rodda | Lab | Reading Central | No | ||
| Matt Turmaine | Lab | Watford | No | ||
| Matt Vickers | Con | Stockton West | Aye | ||
| Matt Western | Lab | Warwick and Leamington | No | ||
| Matthew Patrick | Lab | Wirral West | No | ||
| Maureen Burke | Lab | Glasgow North East | No | ||
| Maya Ellis | Lab | Ribble Valley | No | ||
| Melanie Onn | Lab | Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes | No | ||
| Melanie Ward | Lab | Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy | No | ||
| Miatta Fahnbulleh | Lab | Peckham | No | ||
| Michael Payne | Lab | Gedling | No | ||
| Michael Shanks | Lab | Rutherglen | No | ||
| Michael Wheeler | Lab | Worsley and Eccles | No | ||
| Michelle Scrogham | Lab | Barrow and Furness | No | ||
| Michelle Welsh | Lab | Sherwood Forest | No | ||
| Mike Amesbury | Lab | Runcorn and Helsby | No | ||
| Mike Reader | Lab | Northampton South | No | ||
| Mike Tapp | Lab | Dover and Deal | No | ||
| Mike Wood | Con | Kingswinford and South Staffordshire | Aye | ||
| Mims Davies | Con | East Grinstead and Uckfield | Aye | ||
| Mohammad Yasin | Lab | Bedford | No | ||
| Mr Alex Barros-Curtis | Lab | Cardiff West | No | ||
| Mr Andrew Snowden | Con | Fylde | Aye | ||
| Mr Bayo Alaba | Lab | Southend East and Rochford | No | ||
| Mr Calvin Bailey | Lab | Leyton and Wanstead | No | ||
| Mr Clive Betts | Lab | Sheffield South East | No | ||
| Mr Connor Rand | Lab | Altrincham and Sale West | No | ||
| Mr Douglas Alexander | Lab | Lothian East | No | ||
| Mr Gagan Mohindra | Con | South West Hertfordshire | Aye | ||
| Mr James Frith | Lab | Bury North | No | ||
| Mr Jonathan Brash | Lab | Hartlepool | No | ||
| Mr Louie French | Con | Old Bexley and Sidcup | Aye | ||
| Mr Luke Charters | Lab | York Outer | No | ||
| Mr Mark Francois | Con | Rayleigh and Wickford | Aye | ||
| Mr Paul Foster | Lab | South Ribble | No | ||
| Mr Peter Bedford | Con | Mid Leicestershire | Aye | ||
| Mr Richard Holden | Con | Basildon and Billericay | Aye | ||
| Mr Tanmanjeet Singh Dhesi | Lab | Slough | No | ||
| Mr Toby Perkins | Lab | Chesterfield | No | ||
| Mrs Elsie Blundell | Lab | Heywood and Middleton North | No | ||
| Mrs Kemi Badenoch | Con | North West Essex | Aye | ||
| Mrs Sharon Hodgson | Lab | Washington and Gateshead South | No | ||
| Ms Abena Oppong-Asare | Lab | Erith and Thamesmead | No | ||
| Ms Julie Minns | Lab | Carlisle | No | ||
| Ms Polly Billington | Lab | East Thanet | No | ||
| Ms Stella Creasy | Lab | Walthamstow | No | ||
| Nadia Whittome | Lab | Nottingham East | No | ||
| Natalie Fleet | Lab | Bolsover | No | ||
| Natasha Irons | Lab | Croydon East | No | ||
| Naushabah Khan | Lab | Gillingham and Rainham | No | ||
| Navendu Mishra | Lab | Stockport | No | ||
| Neil Coyle | Lab | Bermondsey and Old Southwark | No | ||
| Neil Duncan-Jordan | Lab | Poole | No | ||
| Neil O'Brien | Con | Harborough, Oadby and Wigston | Aye | ||
| Nesil Caliskan | Lab | Barking | No | ||
| Nick Smith | Lab | Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney | No | ||
| Nick Thomas-Symonds | Lab | Torfaen | No | ||
| Nick Timothy | Con | West Suffolk | Aye | ||
| Nigel Huddleston | Con | Droitwich and Evesham | Aye | ||
| Noah Law | Lab | St Austell and Newquay | No | ||
| Oliver Ryan | Lab | Burnley | No | ||
| Olivia Bailey | Lab | Reading West and Mid Berkshire | No | ||
| Olivia Blake | Lab | Sheffield Hallam | No | ||
| Pam Cox | Lab | Colchester | No | ||
| Pamela Nash | Lab | Motherwell, Wishaw and Carluke | No | ||
| Pat McFadden | Lab | Wolverhampton South East | No | ||
| Patricia Ferguson | Lab | Glasgow West | No | ||
| Patrick Hurley | Lab | Southport | No | ||
| Patrick Spencer | Con | Central Suffolk and North Ipswich | Aye | ||
| Paul Davies | Lab | Colne Valley | No | ||
| Paul Holmes | Con | Hamble Valley | Aye Teller | ||
| Paul Waugh | Lab | Rochdale | No | ||
| Paula Barker | Lab | Liverpool Wavertree | No | ||
| Paulette Hamilton | Lab | Birmingham Erdington | No | ||
| Perran Moon | Lab | Camborne and Redruth | No | ||
| Peter Dowd | Lab | Bootle | No | ||
| Peter Fortune | Con | Bromley and Biggin Hill | Aye | ||
| Peter Kyle | Lab | Hove and Portslade | No | ||
| Peter Lamb | Lab | Crawley | No | ||
| Peter Swallow | Lab | Bracknell | No | ||
| Phil Brickell | Lab | Bolton West | No | ||
| Preet Kaur Gill | Lab | Birmingham Edgbaston | No | ||
| Rachael Maskell | Lab | York Central | No | ||
| Rachel Blake | Lab | Cities of London and Westminster | No | ||
| Rachel Hopkins | Lab | Luton South and South Bedfordshire | No | ||
| Rachel Taylor | Lab | North Warwickshire and Bedworth | No | ||
| Rebecca Harris | Con | Castle Point | Aye | ||
| Rebecca Long Bailey | Ind | Salford | No | ||
| Rebecca Paul | Con | Reigate | Aye | ||
| Rebecca Smith | Con | South West Devon | Aye | ||
| Richard Baker | Lab | Glenrothes and Mid Fife | No | ||
| Richard Burgon | Ind | Leeds East | No | ||
| Richard Fuller | Con | North Bedfordshire | Aye | ||
| Richard Quigley | Lab | Isle of Wight West | No | ||
| Robbie Moore | Con | Keighley and Ilkley | Aye | ||
| Robert Jenrick | Con | Newark | Aye | ||
| Rosie Wrighting | Lab | Kettering | No | ||
| Ruth Cadbury | Lab | Brentford and Isleworth | No | ||
| Ruth Jones | Lab | Newport West and Islwyn | No | ||
| Sadik Al-Hassan | Lab | North Somerset | No | ||
| Sally Jameson | Lab | Doncaster Central | No | ||
| Sam Carling | Lab | North West Cambridgeshire | No | ||
| Sam Rushworth | Lab | Bishop Auckland | No | ||
| Samantha Dixon | Lab | Chester North and Neston | No | ||
| Samantha Niblett | Lab | South Derbyshire | No | ||
| Saqib Bhatti | Con | Meriden and Solihull East | Aye | ||
| Sarah Bool | Con | South Northamptonshire | Aye | ||
| Sarah Champion | Lab | Rotherham | No | ||
| Sarah Coombes | Lab | West Bromwich | No | ||
| Sarah Edwards | Lab | Tamworth | No | ||
| Sarah Hall | Lab | Warrington South | No | ||
| Sarah Jones | Lab | Croydon West | No | ||
| Sarah Owen | Lab | Luton North | No | ||
| Sarah Russell | Lab | Congleton | No | ||
| Satvir Kaur | Lab | Southampton Test | No | ||
| Sean Woodcock | Lab | Banbury | No | ||
| Seema Malhotra | Lab | Feltham and Heston | No | ||
| Shaun Davies | Lab | Telford | No | ||
| Shivani Raja | Con | Leicester East | Aye | ||
| Simon Hoare | Con | North Dorset | Aye | ||
| Simon Lightwood | Lab | Wakefield and Rothwell | No | ||
| Sir Alan Campbell | Lab | Tynemouth | No | ||
| Sir Andrew Mitchell | Con | Sutton Coldfield | Aye | ||
| Sir Ashley Fox | Con | Bridgwater | Aye | ||
| Sir Bernard Jenkin | Con | Harwich and North Essex | Aye | ||
| Sir Desmond Swayne | Con | New Forest West | Aye | ||
| Sir Gavin Williamson | Con | Stone, Great Wyrley and Penkridge | Aye | ||
| Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown | Con | North Cotswolds | Aye | ||
| Sir Geoffrey Cox | Con | Torridge and Tavistock | Aye | ||
| Sir Iain Duncan Smith | Con | Chingford and Woodford Green | Aye | ||
| Sir James Cleverly | Con | Braintree | Aye | ||
| Sir Jeremy Hunt | Con | Godalming and Ash | Aye | ||
| Sir Jeremy Wright | Con | Kenilworth and Southam | Aye | ||
| Sir John Hayes | Con | South Holland and The Deepings | Aye | ||
| Sir John Whittingdale | Con | Maldon | Aye | ||
| Sir Mark Hendrick | Lab | Preston | No | ||
| Sir Mark Tami | Lab | Alyn and Deeside | No | ||
| Sir Mel Stride | Con | Central Devon | Aye | ||
| Sir Nicholas Dakin | Lab | Scunthorpe | No | ||
| Sir Oliver Dowden | Con | Hertsmere | Aye | ||
| Sir Stephen Timms | Lab | East Ham | No | ||
| Sojan Joseph | Lab | Ashford | No | ||
| Sonia Kumar | Lab | Dudley | No | ||
| Stephanie Peacock | Lab | Barnsley South | No | ||
| Stephen Kinnock | Lab | Aberafan Maesteg | No | ||
| Steve Barclay | Con | North East Cambridgeshire | Aye | ||
| Steve Race | Lab | Exeter | No | ||
| Steve Witherden | Lab | Montgomeryshire and Glyndŵr | No | ||
| Steve Yemm | Lab | Mansfield | No | ||
| Stuart Anderson | Con | South Shropshire | Aye Teller | ||
| Stuart Andrew | Con | Daventry | Aye | ||
| Suella Braverman | Con | Fareham and Waterlooville | Aye | ||
| Sureena Brackenridge | Lab | Wolverhampton North East | No | ||
| Tahir Ali | Lab | Birmingham Hall Green and Moseley | No | ||
| Taiwo Owatemi | Lab | Coventry North West | No | ||
| Tim Roca | Lab | Macclesfield | No | ||
| Tom Collins | Lab | Worcester | No | ||
| Tom Hayes | Lab | Bournemouth East | No | ||
| Tom Rutland | Lab | East Worthing and Shoreham | No | ||
| Tom Tugendhat | Con | Tonbridge | Aye | ||
| Tonia Antoniazzi | Lab | Gower | No | ||
| Tony Vaughan | Lab | Folkestone and Hythe | No | ||
| Torcuil Crichton | Lab | Na h-Eileanan an Iar | No | ||
| Torsten Bell | Lab | Swansea West | No | ||
| Tracy Gilbert | Lab | Edinburgh North and Leith | No | ||
| Tristan Osborne | Lab | Chatham and Aylesford | No | ||
| Tulip Siddiq | Lab | Hampstead and Highgate | No | ||
| Uma Kumaran | Lab | Stratford and Bow | No | ||
| Valerie Vaz | Lab | Walsall and Bloxwich | No | ||
| Vicky Foxcroft | Lab | Lewisham North | No | ||
| Victoria Atkins | Con | Louth and Horncastle | Aye | ||
| Wendy Morton | Con | Aldridge-Brownhills | Aye | ||
| Wes Streeting | Lab | Ilford North | No | ||
| Will Stone | Lab | Swindon North | No | ||
| Yasmin Qureshi | Lab | Bolton South and Walkden | No | ||
| Yuan Yang | Lab | Earley and Woodley | No | ||
| Zarah Sultana | Ind | Coventry South | No | ||
| Adam Dance | LD | Yeovil | — | ||
| Adrian Ramsay | Green | Waveney Valley | — | ||
| Alex Brewer | LD | North East Hampshire | — | ||
| Alex Easton | Ind | North Down | — | ||
| Alex Sobel | Lab | Leeds Central and Headingley | — | ||
| Alison Bennett | LD | Mid Sussex | — | ||
| Andrew George | LD | St Ives | — | ||
| Angela Rayner | Lab | Ashton-under-Lyne | — | ||
| Ann Davies | PC | Caerfyrddin | — | ||
| Anna Sabine | LD | Frome and East Somerset | — | ||
| Ayoub Khan | Ind | Birmingham Perry Barr | — | ||
| Bell Ribeiro-Addy | Lab | Clapham and Brixton Hill | — | ||
| Ben Lake | PC | Ceredigion Preseli | — | ||
| Ben Maguire | LD | North Cornwall | — | ||
| Bobby Dean | LD | Carshalton and Wallington | — | ||
| Brendan O'Hara | SNP | Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber | — | ||
| Brian Mathew | LD | Melksham and Devizes | — | ||
| Bridget Phillipson | Lab | Houghton and Sunderland South | — | ||
| Calum Miller | LD | Bicester and Woodstock | — | ||
| Cameron Thomas | Ind | Tewkesbury | — | ||
| Carla Denyer | Green | Bristol Central | — | ||
| Carla Lockhart | DUP | Upper Bann | — | ||
| Caroline Nokes | Con | Romsey and Southampton North | — | ||
| Caroline Voaden | LD | South Devon | — | ||
| Carolyn Harris | Lab | Neath and Swansea East | — | ||
| Cat Eccles | Lab | Stourbridge | — | ||
| Charlie Maynard | LD | Witney | — | ||
| Charlotte Cane | LD | Ely and East Cambridgeshire | — | ||
| Chris Bloore | Lab | Redditch | — | ||
| Chris Bryant | Lab | Rhondda and Ogmore | — | ||
| Chris Coghlan | LD | Dorking and Horley | — | ||
| Chris Evans | Lab | Caerphilly | — | ||
| Chris Hazzard | SF | South Down | — | ||
| Chris Law | SNP | Dundee Central | — | ||
| Christine Jardine | LD | Edinburgh West | — | ||
| Claire Hanna | SDLP | Belfast South and Mid Down | — | ||
| Claire Young | LD | Thornbury and Yate | — | ||
| Clive Jones | LD | Wokingham | — | ||
| Dáire Hughes | SF | Newry and Armagh | — | ||
| Daisy Cooper | LD | St Albans | — | ||
| Dan Jarvis | Lab | Barnsley North | — | ||
| Dan Norris | Ind | North East Somerset and Hanham | — | ||
| Dave Doogan | SNP | Angus and Perthshire Glens | — | ||
| David Chadwick | LD | Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe | — | ||
| David Williams | Lab | Stoke-on-Trent North | — | ||
| Dr Al Pinkerton | LD | Surrey Heath | — | ||
| Dr Danny Chambers | LD | Winchester | — | ||
| Dr Ellie Chowns | Green | North Herefordshire | — | ||
| Dr Rosena Allin-Khan | Lab | Tooting | — | ||
| Dr Roz Savage | LD | South Cotswolds | — | ||
| Ed Davey | LD | Kingston and Surbiton | — | ||
| Ed Miliband | Lab | Doncaster North | — | ||
| Edward Morello | LD | West Dorset | — | ||
| Esther McVey | Con | Tatton | — | ||
| Freddie van Mierlo | LD | Henley and Thame | — | ||
| Gideon Amos | LD | Taunton and Wellington | — | ||
| Graham Leadbitter | SNP | Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey | — | ||
| Helen Grant | Con | Maidstone and Malling | — | ||
| Helen Maguire | LD | Epsom and Ewell | — | ||
| Helen Morgan | LD | North Shropshire | — | ||
| Ian Byrne | Lab | Liverpool West Derby | — | ||
| Ian Roome | LD | North Devon | — | ||
| Ian Sollom | LD | St Neots and Mid Cambridgeshire | — | ||
| James MacCleary | LD | Lewes | — | ||
| James McMurdock | Ind | South Basildon and East Thurrock | — | ||
| Jamie Stone | LD | Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross | — | ||
| Janet Daby | Lab | Lewisham East | — | ||
| Jess Brown-Fuller | LD | Chichester | — | ||
| Jesse Norman | Con | Hereford and South Herefordshire | — | ||
| Jim Allister | TUV | North Antrim | — | ||
| Joe Powell | Lab | Kensington and Bayswater | — | ||
| John Finucane | SF | Belfast North | — | ||
| John Milne | LD | Horsham | — | ||
| Jonathan Reynolds | Lab | Stalybridge and Hyde | — | ||
| Josh Babarinde | LD | Eastbourne | — | ||
| Judith Cummins | Lab | Bradford South | — | ||
| Kenneth Stevenson | Lab | Airdrie and Shotts | — | ||
| Kerry McCarthy | Lab | Bristol East | — | ||
| Kirsty Blackman | SNP | Aberdeen North | — | ||
| Laura Trott | Con | Sevenoaks | — | ||
| Layla Moran | LD | Oxford West and Abingdon | — | ||
| Lee Anderson | RUK | Ashfield | — | ||
| Lisa Nandy | Lab | Wigan | — | ||
| Lisa Smart | LD | Hazel Grove | — | ||
| Liz Jarvis | LD | Eastleigh | — | ||
| Liz Saville Roberts | PC | Dwyfor Meirionnydd | — | ||
| Llinos Medi | PC | Ynys Môn | — | ||
| Lorraine Beavers | Lab | Blackpool North and Fleetwood | — | ||
| Luke Taylor | LD | Sutton and Cheam | — | ||
| Manuela Perteghella | LD | Stratford-on-Avon | — | ||
| Marie Goldman | LD | Chelmsford | — | ||
| Martin Wrigley | LD | Newton Abbot | — | ||
| Mary Creagh | Lab | Coventry East | — | ||
| Mary Kelly Foy | Lab | City of Durham | — | ||
| Matthew Pennycook | Lab | Greenwich and Woolwich | — | ||
| Max Wilkinson | LD | Cheltenham | — | ||
| Mike Kane | Lab | Wythenshawe and Sale East | — | ||
| Mike Martin | LD | Tunbridge Wells | — | ||
| Monica Harding | LD | Esher and Walton | — | ||
| Mr Adnan Hussain | Ind | Blackburn | — | ||
| Mr Alistair Carmichael | LD | Orkney and Shetland | — | ||
| Mr Angus MacDonald | LD | Inverness, Skye and West Ross-shire | — | ||
| Mr Cathal Mallaghan | SF | Mid Ulster | — | ||
| Mr David Lammy | Lab | Tottenham | — | ||
| Mr Gregory Campbell | DUP | East Londonderry | — | ||
| Mr Hamish Falconer | Lab | Lincoln | — | ||
| Mr Joshua Reynolds | LD | Maidenhead | — | ||
| Mr Lee Dillon | LD | Newbury | — | ||
| Mr Paul Kohler | LD | Wimbledon | — | ||
| Mr Will Forster | LD | Woking | — | ||
| Ms Diane Abbott | Ind | Hackney North and Stoke Newington | — | ||
| Ms Marie Rimmer | Lab | St Helens South and Whiston | — | ||
| Ms Nusrat Ghani | Con | Sussex Weald | — | ||
| Munira Wilson | LD | Twickenham | — | ||
| Naz Shah | Lab | Bradford West | — | ||
| Nigel Farage | RUK | Clacton | — | ||
| Olly Glover | LD | Didcot and Wantage | — | ||
| Órfhlaith Begley | SF | West Tyrone | — | ||
| Pat Cullen | SF | Fermanagh and South Tyrone | — | ||
| Paul Maskey | SF | Belfast West | — | ||
| Pete Wishart | SNP | Perth and Kinross-shire | — | ||
| Pippa Heylings | LD | South Cambridgeshire | — | ||
| Priti Patel | Con | Witham | — | ||
| Rachel Gilmour | LD | Tiverton and Minehead | — | ||
| Rachel Reeves | Lab | Leeds West and Pudsey | — | ||
| Richard Foord | LD | Honiton and Sidmouth | — | ||
| Richard Tice | RUK | Boston and Skegness | — | ||
| Rishi Sunak | Con | Richmond and Northallerton | — | ||
| Robin Swann | UUP | South Antrim | — | ||
| Rosie Duffield | Ind | Canterbury | — | ||
| Rupert Lowe | RB | Great Yarmouth | — | ||
| Rushanara Ali | Lab | Bethnal Green and Stepney | — | ||
| Sammy Wilson | DUP | East Antrim | — | ||
| Sarah Dyke | LD | Glastonbury and Somerton | — | ||
| Sarah Gibson | LD | Chippenham | — | ||
| Sarah Green | LD | Chesham and Amersham | — | ||
| Sarah Olney | LD | Richmond Park | — | ||
| Sarah Sackman | Lab | Finchley and Golders Green | — | ||
| Sarah Smith | Lab | Hyndburn | — | ||
| Seamus Logan | SNP | Aberdeenshire North and Moray East | — | ||
| Shabana Mahmood | Lab | Birmingham Ladywood | — | ||
| Shockat Adam | Ind | Leicester South | — | ||
| Siân Berry | Green | Brighton Pavilion | — | ||
| Sir Alec Shelbrooke | Con | Wetherby and Easingwold | — | ||
| Sir Christopher Chope | Con | Christchurch | — | ||
| Sir Edward Leigh | Con | Gainsborough | — | ||
| Sir Julian Lewis | Con | New Forest East | — | ||
| Sir Julian Smith | Con | Skipton and Ripon | — | ||
| Sir Keir Starmer | Lab | Holborn and St Pancras | — | ||
| Sir Lindsay Hoyle | Spk | Chorley | — | ||
| Sir Roger Gale | Con | Herne Bay and Sandwich | — | ||
| Sorcha Eastwood | APNI | Lagan Valley | — | ||
| Steff Aquarone | LD | North Norfolk | — | ||
| Stephen Doughty | Lab | Cardiff South and Penarth | — | ||
| Stephen Flynn | SNP | Aberdeen South | — | ||
| Stephen Gethins | SNP | Arbroath and Broughty Ferry | — | ||
| Stephen Morgan | Lab | Portsmouth South | — | ||
| Steve Darling | LD | Torbay | — | ||
| Steve Reed | Lab | Streatham and Croydon North | — | ||
| Susan Murray | LD | Mid Dunbartonshire | — | ||
| Terry Jermy | Lab | South West Norfolk | — | ||
| Tessa Munt | LD | Wells and Mendip Hills | — | ||
| Tim Farron | LD | Westmorland and Lonsdale | — | ||
| Tom Gordon | LD | Harrogate and Knaresborough | — | ||
| Tom Morrison | LD | Cheadle | — | ||
| Victoria Collins | LD | Harpenden and Berkhamsted | — | ||
| Vikki Slade | LD | Mid Dorset and North Poole | — | ||
| Warinder Juss | Lab | Wolverhampton West | — | ||
| Wendy Chamberlain | LD | North East Fife | — | ||
| Wera Hobhouse | LD | Bath | — | ||
| Yvette Cooper | Lab | Pontefract, Castleford and Knottingley | — | ||
| Zöe Franklin | LD | Guildford | — |
Primary source
Commons Votes API JSON
Official page
Parliament division page
Hansard debate
View debate in Hansard
Hansard division
View division in Hansard
FAQs
What was the result of this Commons division?
This division was rejected, with 109 Ayes and 366 Noes. Source
What is a Commons division?
A Commons division is a recorded vote in the House of Commons where MPs are recorded as voting Aye or No. Source
How many MPs voted in this division?
478 MPs have an imported recorded vote for this division. Source
What does did not vote mean on this division?
Did not vote means there is no imported Aye or No vote for that MP in this division. It does not by itself explain the reason. Source
What does rebel mean on this division?
Rebel means the MP's recorded vote differed from the majority recorded vote of their party in this division. Independent and Speaker roles are not labelled as rebels because they do not have a party whip. Source
What does party position mean on this division?
Party position is the direction the majority of a party's voting members took in this division — Aye or No. Parliament does not publish official whipping instructions, so this is derived from the recorded votes rather than from a stated whip. Source
Where does this division data come from?
This division and its vote records come from the Commons Votes API. Source
What bill is this division about?
This division is linked to the Budget Responsibility Act 2024 (Government Bill). Bill data comes from the UK Parliament Bills API. Source